Robert Handy Expert Report regarding LAPD Shooting involving Officers Zavala and Quintanilla
About this document
- Layer
- attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
- Type as titled
- sme report (kind from doc_type)
- File
- f0e56d92560ff7aa0d5c7a58497aad2f16fccab6 application/pdf
- Cases
About: Jose Zavala (case), Julio Quintanilla (case)
Expert Report: Robert Handy
LAPD OIS on 12-18-2021
Involving Officers Zavala and Quintanilla
coverage next to Officer 1, did not fire
- • Less lethal was available immediately next to Officer Zavala (Officer 4 with a stun bag shotgun), but was not utilized.
- • The organization of this small team of officers was designed to provide less-lethal options for each grouping of officers. Victim's initial movement (4 steps) just before being shot was toward Officers O-1 and Meraz; thus, the 40 mm (Officer 1) was ordered deployed by Sergeant and fired by Officer 1.
- • There were at least eight officers present and organized to deal with any of the possible scenarios that Officers Zavala and Quintanilla stated they feared, and as reasons they shot Victim.
- • Based on the totality of the circumstances, Victim's turning toward Officers Zavala and Quintanilla does not constitute an imminent threat as defined in California law.
"A threat of death or serious bodily injury is 'imminent' when, based on the totality of the circumstances, a reasonable officer in the same situation would believe that a person has the present ability, opportunity, and apparent intent to immediately cause death or serious bodily injury to the peace officer or another person. An imminent harm is not merely a fear of future harm, no matter how great the fear and no matter how great the likelihood of the harm, but is one that, from appearances, must be instantly confronted and addressed37."
Throughout the videos and all the materials available, I did not see, hear, or review any documented direct threats toward the officers or any other person. Victim was suicidal, a threat to himself, and posed many potential threatening scenarios based on possible actions. When Victim stood up and stepped toward the officers, the situation was changing. The officers were set up to prevent Victim's movement and to address potential threatening scenarios under the direction of Sergeant. Sergeant ordered the second 40mm less lethal deployment. When the 40mm round was ordered, Victim had started moving forward in the direction of Officers O-1 and Meraz.
By the time the 40mm was deployed, Victim was no longer moving forward toward Officers O-1 and Meraz; he was turning his body and feet toward Officers Zavala, Quintanilla, and Officer 4. When Victim was stepping toward Officer 1 and turning toward Officer Zavala, the movements were not hurried. He was not running, lunging, or aggressively advancing toward the officers. Victim's turn toward Officer Zavala was also at normal speed and did not appear to be a sudden or aggressive move.
37 CA Penal Code 835(a)(e)(2)
13
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.