Robert Handy Expert Report regarding LAPD Shooting involving Officers Zavala and Quintanilla
About this document
- Layer
- attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
- Type as titled
- sme report (kind from doc_type)
- File
- f0e56d92560ff7aa0d5c7a58497aad2f16fccab6 application/pdf
- Cases
About: Jose Zavala (case), Julio Quintanilla (case)
Expert Report: Robert Handy
LAPD OIS on 12-18-2021
Involving Officers Zavala and Quintanilla
west, facing Officers Zavala and Quintanilla. Officer Zavala fired first, three times, then Officer Quintanilla fired one time34.
At the time the shots were fired, the officers were each standing behind vehicle doors equipped with ballistic protection panels. Officer Zavala was approximately 25 feet away from Victim, and Officer Quintanilla was approximately 28 feet away from Victim. Both officers indicated that they fired because they thought Victim was going to cause serious bodily injury or death. For example, Officer Zavala told investigators, "The suspect then starts advancing towards the officers and turns his body towards myself and my partner. And in fear --I was afraid, sir. I thought this guy was going to come at me with this butcher knife." Officer Quintanilla told investigators, "He was coming towards us. He was going to cause myself or my partner serious bodily injury. He was going to cause death."
While the officers' reasons for firing their weapons are reasonable fears of what could happen, they are speculative and do not amount to imminent harm as defined by the California Penal Code. Factors indicating Victim was not an imminent threat include:
- • Victim, at the time he was shot, was standing, facing officers Zavala and Quintanilla, not advancing on them
- • Less lethal tools were in place in two directions, including next to Officer Zavala (Officer 4 with a beanbag)35
- • Both officers were standing behind the police vehicle doors with ballistic panels more than 28 feet away from Victim
- • Sergeant ordered the less-lethal rounds to be fired moments before the officers fired their handguns
- • A 40 mm less lethal round was fired a second time, less than one second before Officer Zavala fired from his handgun. There was no opportunity to see if the less lethal, ordered by the sergeant, was effective
- • There were multiple officers and options available to try and stop Victim had he advanced toward Officers Zavala and Quintanilla
- • There were officers closer to Victim than Officer Zavala and Quintanilla, who did not fire their handguns. Officers O-1 and Meraz were approximately 22 feet away from Victim when Officer Zavala first fired36. Officer 1 fired the 40 mm as directed, less than one second before Officer Zavala fired his handgun. Officer Meraz, who was providing lethal
34 Zavala, Quintanilla, Sergeant BWC video, FID Report
35 FID Report page, 14
36 FID Report page, 16
12
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.