Documents › a08af50d4cb71291ce26573f357d57f47ca4f808:1-13

Daly City Notice of Intent to Terminate Kevin Smithmatungol

POST board disciplinediscipline and employment 2025-06-02 13 pages (file pages 1–13) original file
About this document
Layer
attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
Type as titled
notice of intent to terminate (kind from doc_type)
File
a08af50d4cb71291ce26573f357d57f47ca4f808 application/pdf
Cases
POST 2505112 · Kevin Smithmatungol (filed under case)

About: Kevin Smithmatungol (case)

Page 8 · file page 8 larger image
Image of page 8; its text is alongside
Text: OCR
    • February 23, 2024 – You were involved in a vehicle pursuit where it was determined you were out of policy for unsafe speeds and improper driving behavior, resulting in a documented counseling.
    • September 29, 2024 – You conducted a death investigation (24005954) and the family indicated suspicious circumstances surrounding the death of the victim. While making notifications to the coroner, you muted your body camera, and it was determined information relayed to the coroner likely lacked the information noted above, which may have changed the decision by the coroner to respond to the scene. We were unable to verify this as the conversation was not captured on BWC. You were issued documented counseling.
    • October 27, 2024 – You arrested a subject for felony charges and collected several items of property from them (case #24006597). On October 28, 2024, property room specialist Ben Bermudez e-mailed you about a purse that was shown as booked into the evidence locker as safekeeping. Bermudez spoke with you in person later that same day about the missing purse and you told him it was an oversight, and that the purse was in the trunk of your patrol vehicle, challenging the integrity of any chain of custody for the purse. You booked the purse into property later that evening, and Bermudez again sent you another e-mail on October 29, 2024, as there were narcotics, drug paraphernalia, and a check book belonging to someone other than the person you arrested, all requiring different handling procedures. You received a Letter of Reprimand for violation of Lexipol Policy 803.3.2, Narcotics and Dangerous Drugs (booking procedures), 803.3, Property Handling, 340.5.8(b), Efficiency, and Manual of Rules 3.60, Performance of Duty. This Letter of Reprimand followed previous discussions as noted by Lieutenant Klier in your Letter of Reprimand dated December 21, 2024.
    • January 18, 2025 (25000342) – You were involved in a pursuit that ended up at Cesar Chavez Street and Vermont Street, San Francisco. It was determined you were driving too fast for conditions during the pursuit, and you collided with a cement center median. The collision was deemed preventable with the associated factor of inattention as you were reaching for your police radio while trying to manage a turn. A Disciplinary Review Board was held on February 25, 2025, as you had previous preventable collisions. Disciplinary decisions were withheld pending the three pending Internal Affairs investigations.
    • February 27, 2025 – You were placed on Administrative Leave, as concerns about your performance and decision making were in question from the above performance issues and the three pending Internal Affairs investigations contained in this notice.

V. ANALYSIS

In Skelly v. State Personnel Bd. (1975) 15 Cal.3d 194, the California Supreme Court held that in considering the propriety of public employee disciplinary action:

“...the overriding consideration in these cases is the extent to which the employee’s conduct resulted in, or if repeated is likely to result in harm

8

12904989.1 DA003-026

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.