Daly City Notice of Intent to Terminate Kevin Smithmatungol
About this document
- Layer
- attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
- Type as titled
- notice of intent to terminate (kind from doc_type)
- File
- a08af50d4cb71291ce26573f357d57f47ca4f808 application/pdf
- Cases
About: Kevin Smithmatungol (case)
Sergeant Douglas did not recall hearing you put yourself out for subpoena attempts over the radio, which she characterized as unusual for you. She also confirmed you had no self-generated subpoena attempts in the computer-aided dispatch system.
The evidence demonstrates that you did not attempt to serve either subpoena. As for the first subpoena for an address on [REDACTED] review of both in-car and fixed license plate reader data suggested you never drove on [REDACTED]. You listed 9:23 p.m. as the attempted service time for the subpoena on [REDACTED] however you were on a call for service from 9:05 p.m. to 9:30 p.m. at another location for a shoplifting investigation at the Ross Store located in the Westlake Shopping Center. A review of residential cameras and an interview with residents for the subpoena on [REDACTED] also support that you did not attempt service of the [REDACTED] subpoena as you had noted.
As for the second subpoena for an address on [REDACTED] while you did drive on the street, neither time noted in the data (8:53 p.m. and 10:19 p.m.) aligned with your supposed service attempt at 9:42 p.m. Additional evidence confirmed you were not in the area throughout your shift, proving you did not attempt service on [REDACTED].
During your internal affairs interview, you stated that "No Answer" meant you attempted in-person contact at the residence and did not receive a responsive answer and left. Specifically, you stated that when using the disposition of "No Answer," you would park your car, walk up, knock, not receive an answer, and leave. At first, you stated that you did not recall serving the subpoenas in question. After additional questioning, you affirmed your attempts to serve the two subpoenas in question. When confronted with the evidence proving you could not have attempted service of the subpoenas as noted, you were unable to provide clear, consistent, or convincing information to support your statements. Eventually, you stated that you could not remember the events and could not understand the origin of the times you noted on the subpoenas.
Additionally, you stated that you do not activate your Body Worn Camera (BWC) on subpoena attempts unless someone opens the door or you make contact with someone. An audit of the Versaterrm Cad system and Evidence.com disproved your statement that your standard practice is to only activate your BWC upon citizen contact. Two out of the three subpoena attempts conducted by you prior and following October 25, 2024 indicate that you activated your BWC as you approached the residence and before making any contact with any persons.
IV. DISCIPLINE PRIOR TO AND DURING AFOREMENTIONED INCIDENTS
Your performance history and previous counseling and discipline were considered when evaluating the decision to terminate. The following further supports my proposal to terminate your employment.
-
- October 7, 2023 – You were involved in a preventable collision where you side-swiped a parked car, resulting in a documented counseling.
-
- October 30, 2023 – You were involved in a preventable collision during a pursuit, resulting in a documented counseling.
7
12904989.1 DA003-026
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.