Cases › board:POST2505112

POST case 2505112

POST board · board proceeding · Kevin Smithmatungol · Daly City Police Department
Case id
POST2505112
POST number
2505112
Agency case no.
IA #24-04 | IA #24-06 | IA #24-07
Incident dates
2024-06-02 – 2024-10-25 (3 incidents)
Category
dishonesty
POST outcome
revocation at posaab, 2026-07-16

Summary model-written

Officer Kevin Smithmatungol was found to have committed multiple acts of dishonesty, including lying about obtaining a fingerprint, fabricating an alibi for being late to training, and falsely reporting the attempted service of subpoenas. The POST Division found clear and convincing evidence of serious misconduct, and the POSAAB unanimously recommended the revocation of his certification.

Officer

Name
Kevin Smithmatungol
POST ID
C88-Y32 (id~1+name)
Name in NPI
KEVIN SMITHMATUNGOL

Search within this case's documents →

Proceedings 6

Extracted and classified by a model, quote is verbatim from source text

  1. 2025-06-12
    agency
    made initial notifications to Division of each of the Administrative Investigations and provided the Administrative Investigation reports
    source · quote found
    On June 12, 2025, DCPD made initial notifications to Division of each of the Administrative Investigations and provided the Administrative Investigation reports.
    page 318
  2. 2025-08-15
    agency
    resigned
    source · quote found
    On August 15, 2025, the Respondent attended an administrative meeting, where he resigned effective October 1, 2025.
    page 3
  3. 2026-01-13
    division
    interviewed respondent
    source · quote found
    On January 13, 2026, the Respondent was interviewed by POST LEC Christina Moore and LEC Kevin Sherburne
    page 309
  4. 2026-02-18
    division
    served the Division's Notice of Determination Report and accompanying Notice of Intent to Revoke Certification
    Certification: revocation
    source · quote found
    Respondent was served with the Division's Notice of Determination Report and accompanying Notice of Intent to Revoke Certification, notifying Respondent the Division found reasonable grounds for revocation of Respondent's POST certification, on February 18, 2026.
    page 274
  5. 2026-03-10
    respondent
    requested a review of the Division's determination and reasons for revocation
    source · quote found
    Respondent requested a review of the Division's determination and reasons for revocation of Respondent's POST certification on March 10, 2026
    page 274
  6. 2026-07-16
    posaab
    held hearing and recommended revocation
    Certification: revocation · vote unanimously
    source · quote found
    Motion carries unanimously.
    page 308

Incidents 3

DateConductCategoryFindingDiscipline / outcome
2024-06-02 Respondent claimed to have obtained a subject's fingerprint when asked by a supervisor how a shoplifting subject was identified, and later repeated this false statement during an Internal Affairs interview on January 31, 2025. dishonesty sustained
Division: clear and convincing evidence the Respondent committed serious misconduct
served a Notice of Intent to Discipline on June 2, 2025
Evidence · quote found
On June 2, 2024, the Respondent responded to the Target retail store... claimed to have obtained the subject’s fingerprint, when he had not. During his Internal Affairs interview, the Respondent again claimed to have obtained the subject’s fingerprint when he had not.
2024-06-20 Respondent falsely told supervisors he was addressing evidence with the Property Room Manager to explain being late for training, sent a text to the manager to support this alibi, and lied about it during an Internal Affairs interview on January 31, 2025. dishonesty sustained
Division: clear and convincing evidence the Respondent committed serious misconduct
served a Notice of Intent to Discipline on June 2, 2025
Evidence · quote found
On June 20, 2024, when asked by his supervisors as to why the Respondent had arrived late for his scheduled training day, the Respondent explained he was addressing some outstanding evidence with the Property Room Manager.
2024-10-25 Respondent informed his supervisor and wrote on return slips that he attempted to serve two subpoenas when he had not, and later lied about this during an Internal Affairs interview on January 31, 2025, claiming GPS would prove his location. dishonesty sustained
Division: clear and convincing evidence the Respondent committed serious misconduct
served a Notice of Intent to Discipline on June 2, 2025
Evidence · quote found
On October 25, 2024, the Respondent was assigned two (2) subpoenas to serve. The Respondent informed his supervisor and wrote on the subpoena return slip that he had attempted to serve each subpoena when he had not.

Documents 51

agency investigation 23

DocumentKindDatePagesSourceLinked by
Daly City Police Department Administrative Investigative Memorandum 24-04 (Officer Smithmatungol) investigation report 2024 12 Board filed under case
Daly City Police Department Administrative Investigation 24-07 (Officer Smithmatungol) investigation report 2025-01-30 9 Board filed under case
Daly City Police Department Administrative Interview Transcript 24-07 (Kevin Smithmatungol) interview transcript 2025-01-31 14 Board filed under case
Daly City Police Department Administrative Interview Transcript - Kevin Smithmatungol interview transcript 2025-01-31 10 Board filed under case
Daly City Police Department Administrative Interview Transcript 24-06 (Kevin Smithmatungol) interview transcript 2025-01-31 13 Board filed under case
Daly City Police Department Administrative Investigation 24-06 (Officer Smithmatungol) investigation report 2025-05-09 8 Board filed under case
POST Administrative Interview of Kevin Smithmatungol interview transcript 2026-01-13 38 Board filed under case
Request for Review of Peace Officer Certification - Kevin Smithmatungol complaint 2026-03-10 1 Board filed under case
POST Investigative Summary and Findings - Kevin Smithmatungol investigation report 2026-04-14 22 Board filed under case
783 - BR04_POST2505112_Smithmatungol Kevin_Att.C_Administrative Investigative Memorandum Excerpts 24-04.pdf investigation report 2026-07-16 12 Board packet item
783 - BR05_POST2505112_Smithmatungol Kevin_Att.D_Administrative Interview Transcript 24-04.pdf interview transcript 2026-07-16 10 Board packet item
783 - BR06_POST2505112_Smithmatungol Kevin_Att.E_Administrative Investigative Memorandum Excerpts 24-06.pdf investigation report 2026-07-16 8 Board packet item
783 - BR07_POST2505112_Smithmatungol Kevin_Att.F_Administrative Interview Transcript 24-06.pdf interview transcript 2026-07-16 13 Board packet item
783 - BR08_POST2505112_Smithmatungol Kevin_Att.G_Administrative Investigative Memorandum Excerpts 24-07.pdf investigation report 2026-07-16 9 Board packet item
783 - BR09_POST2505112_Smithmatungol Kevin_Att.H_Administrative Interview Transcript 24-07.pdf interview transcript 2026-07-16 14 Board packet item
783 - BR012_POST2505112_Smithmatungol Kevin_Att.K_Division Interview Transcript.pdf interview transcript 2026-07-16 38 Board packet item
-807- - BR012_POST2505112_Smithmatungol Kevin_Att.K_Division Interview Transcript.pdf interview transcript 2026-09-17 38 Board packet item
-807- - BR04_POST2505112_Smithmatungol Kevin_Att.C_Administrative Investigative Memorandum Excerpts 24-04.pdf investigation report 2026-09-17 12 Board packet item
-807- - BR05_POST2505112_Smithmatungol Kevin_Att.D_Administrative Interview Transcript 24-04.pdf interview transcript 2026-09-17 10 Board packet item
-807- - BR06_POST2505112_Smithmatungol Kevin_Att.E_Administrative Investigative Memorandum Excerpts 24-06.pdf investigation report 2026-09-17 8 Board packet item
-807- - BR07_POST2505112_Smithmatungol Kevin_Att.F_Administrative Interview Transcript 24-06.pdf interview transcript 2026-09-17 13 Board packet item
-807- - BR08_POST2505112_Smithmatungol Kevin_Att.G_Administrative Investigative Memorandum Excerpts 24-07.pdf investigation report 2026-09-17 9 Board packet item
-807- - BR09_POST2505112_Smithmatungol Kevin_Att.H_Administrative Interview Transcript 24-07.pdf interview transcript 2026-09-17 14 Board packet item

board proceeding 17

DocumentKindDatePagesSourceLinked by
POST Executive Review & Peace Officer Standards Accountability Division Recommendation - Kevin Smithmatungol executive review 2026-02-11 3 Board filed under case
783 - Cover Page agenda item report 2026-07-16 3 Board packet item
783 - BR01_POST2505112_Smithmatungol Kevin_ISF.pdf investigative summary 2026-07-16 22 Board packet item
783 - BR02_POST2505112_Smithmatungol Kevin_Executive Review Division Recommendation.pdf executive review 2026-07-16 3 Board packet item
POSAAB Agenda Item Report - Kevin Smithmatungol (POST2505112) agenda item report 2026-07-16 3 Board filed under case
POSAAB Agenda Item Report - Kevin Smithmatungol (POST2505112) agenda item report 2026-07-16 3 Board filed under case
POSAAB Board Recommendation re: Peace Officer Certification - Kevin Smithmatungol board recommendation 2026-07-16 3 Board filed under case
POSAAB Meeting Transcript July 16, 2026 hearing transcript 2026-07-16 33 Board filed under case
-807- - Cover Page agenda item report 2026-09-17 4 Board packet item
-807- - BR01_POST2505112_Smithmatungol Kevin_ISF.pdf investigative summary 2026-09-17 22 Board packet item
-807- - BR02_POST2505112_Smithmatungol Kevin_Executive Review Division Recommendation.pdf executive review 2026-09-17 3 Board packet item
-807- - POST2505112_Smithmatungol_Kevin_July_2026_POSAAB_Agenda_Record.pdf posaab agenda record 2026-09-17 6 Board packet item
-807- - POST2505112 _Smithmatungol_Kevin_Board_Hearing_Public_Comment public comment 2026-09-17 3 Board packet item
-807- - POST2505112_Smithmatungol_Kevin_Board_Hearing_Public_Comment_Follow Up public comment 2026-09-17 2 Board packet item
-807- - POST2505112_Smithmatungol_Kevin_Board_Recommendation_Signed.pdf board recommendation 2026-09-17 3 Board packet item
-807- - POST2505112_Smithmatungol_Kevin_Transcript_Board_07.16.26..pdf hearing transcript 2026-09-17 33 Board packet item
Agenda Item Report - Kevin Smithmatungol (POST2505112) agenda item report 2026-09-17 4 Board filed under case

correspondence and logs 2

DocumentKindDatePagesSourceLinked by
Letter from Robert W. Nichelini regarding Kevin Smithmatungol correspondence 2026-03-10 2 Board filed under case
Rains Lucia Stern St. Phalle & Silver Letter on Behalf of Kevin Smithmatungol correspondence 2026-06-30 2 Board filed under case

discipline and employment 9

DocumentKindDatePagesSourceLinked by
Daly City Notice of Intent to Terminate Kevin Smithmatungol discipline 2025-06-02 13 Board filed under case
Kevin Smithmatungol Letter of Resignation discipline 2025-09-22 1 Board filed under case
POST Profile - Kevin Smithmatungol personnel record 2025-11-18 3 Board filed under case
783 - BR03_POST2505112_Smithmatungol Kevin_POST Profile.pdf personnel record 2026-07-16 3 Board packet item
783 - BR010_POST2505112_Smithmatungol Kevin_Att.I_Notice of Intent to Terminate.pdf discipline 2026-07-16 13 Board packet item
783 - BR011_POST2505112_Smithmatungol Kevin_Att.J_Letter of Resignation.pdf discipline 2026-07-16 1 Board packet item
-807- - BR03_POST2505112_Smithmatungol Kevin_POST Profile.pdf personnel record 2026-09-17 3 Board packet item
-807- - BR010_POST2505112_Smithmatungol Kevin_Att.I_Notice of Intent to Terminate.pdf discipline 2026-09-17 13 Board packet item
-807- - BR011_POST2505112_Smithmatungol Kevin_Att.J_Letter of Resignation.pdf discipline 2026-09-17 1 Board packet item