Documents › a08af50d4cb71291ce26573f357d57f47ca4f808:1-13

Daly City Notice of Intent to Terminate Kevin Smithmatungol

POST board disciplinediscipline and employment 2025-06-02 13 pages (file pages 1–13) original file
About this document
Layer
attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
Type as titled
notice of intent to terminate (kind from doc_type)
File
a08af50d4cb71291ce26573f357d57f47ca4f808 application/pdf
Cases
POST 2505112 · Kevin Smithmatungol (filed under case)

About: Kevin Smithmatungol (case)

Page 9 · file page 9 larger image
Image of page 9; its text is alongside
Text: OCR

to the public service.... Other relevant factors include the circumstances surrounding the misconduct and the likelihood of its recurrence.”

As explained below, the investigations have demonstrated that your conduct has demonstrated multiple policy violations, including a pattern of dishonesty that undermines your ability to perform your duties. This conduct has harmed the public service, if repeated, will further harm the public service, and there are no mitigating factors to counter the facts of your dishonesty. Engaging in dishonesty is not compatible with your job as a Daly City police officer. A police officer’s job "is a position of trust and the public has a right to the highest standard of behavior from those they invest with the power and authority of a law enforcement officer. (County of Los Angeles v. Civil Service Com. of County of Los Angeles (2019) 40 Cal.App.5th 871, 878; see also Ackerman v. State Personnel Bd. (1983) 145 Cal.App.3d 395, 400.) Termination of employment for dishonest behavior is appropriate discipline even where the employee was a long-term employee with little or no record of prior discipline. (See, e.g., Nicolini v. Tuolumne (1987) 190 Cal.App.3d 619 [termination of a deputy sheriff for dishonesty upheld where the deputy had nine years of service and no prior discipline]); Paulino v. Civil Service Commission (1985) 175 Cal.App.3d 962, 971 [discharge of police officer for falsely reporting sick leave upheld].) Dishonesty is intolerable conduct for any employee of the Department, and there is no other reasonable choice but dismissal from employment. The principles set forth in these authorities amply support the proposed discipline of termination.

A. YOU WERE DISHONEST AND DEMONSTRATED A LACK OF INTEGRITY ON MULTIPLE OCCASIONS

    1. In the June 2, 2024, incident, you told your supervisor you obtained a thumbprint from a subject you failed to adequately identify before citing them out. Evidence in the internal affairs investigation revealed you did not have an electronic thumbprint device on your digital ticket writer. When confronted with that information by your supervisor, you then stated you took the subject to your patrol vehicle to obtain an ink thumbprint. Again, evidence, to include an audit of your ticket writer, video footage from Target and the body cameras of officers on-scene, revealed you did not escort the subject to your car like you stated, nor did you print a second copy of the citation or obtain an ink thumbprint. You maintained your statement in discussion with your direct supervisors, as well as during your internal affairs investigation, regardless of the evidence disproving your statement at all levels. Your false statements regarding the June 2, 2024 petty theft arrest, claiming you obtained a thumbprint and created a second citation when body-worn camera footage and store surveillance footage prove you did not, constitute deliberate deception. Your conduct misled supervisors and obstructed their ability to ensure compliance with lawful citation and booking procedures. Further, during the internal affairs investigation, you continued to deny wrongdoing, despite overwhelming evidence to the contrary, demonstrating not only your inability to own up to your mistakes but worse, your effortless willingness to lie.
    1. Similarly, in the June 20, 2024, incident, you told your direct supervisor you were downstairs meeting with the property room manager when you showed up to work for a training class 45-minutes late. Furthermore, you sent a text message to the property room supervisor asking them to tell your supervisor that you had met with her if she was asked,

9

12904989.1 DA003-026

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.