Documents › f2b3769d4e3df6a088e9097f582ca46c90a6d63a:1-20

Hearing Officer Recommendation - City of Brentwood - Paul Matejcek Appeal

POST board investigation reportagency investigation 2023-12-12 20 pages (file pages 1–20) original file
About this document
Layer
attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
Type as titled
hearing officer recommendation (kind from doc_type)
File
f2b3769d4e3df6a088e9097f582ca46c90a6d63a application/pdf
Cases
POST 2300017 · Paul Matejcek (filed under case)

About: Paul Matejcek (case)

Page 17 · file page 17 larger image
Image of page 17; its text is alongside
Text: OCR

Recommendation – City of Brentwood – Paul Matecjek Appeal: Paul D. Roose, Hearing Officer


would respond. He had time to confer with his fellow officers on scene about how to respond if she stood up.

The Appellant recalled that he gave verbal commands to █ to “sit down” as she began to stand up. Unfortunately, Officer Franson turned off the BWC audio prior to the standing up / kicking incident. Those commands cannot be verified. Officer Franson did not recall if the Appellant did or did not give commands.

Even without the audio, the video appears to show that the Appellant gave no command as █ began to rise to her feet. If he did give a command, he did not allow sufficient time to see if █ would comply. Had he given a command, she might have ignored or defied it. Nonetheless, verbal commands would have been appropriate in this situation as a first resort prior to kicking █ back to the ground.

The neutral observer concludes the following from watching the BWC video of the incident: that, for a second during an otherwise well-handled situation, the Appellant lost his cool. Without checking with his fellow officers, and without apparent forethought, he kicked / pushed █ to the ground. This conduct was not reasonable. As former BPD training officer Nance stated, the Appellant erred in his “decision-making,” not in his technique. Just cause exists for disciplining the Appellant for violating the department’s use of force policy.

The Department Abused its Discretion by Selecting the Termination Penalty:10 Discipline for the April 23, 2022 incident is warranted. The Employer met its burden that the Appellant used excessive force on that date.

The next question is the appropriate penalty. The BPD policy manual allows for written reprimands, demotions, and suspensions without pay (among other choices) as disciplinary options. The policy manual makes it clear that a hearing officer is restricted to exploring two questions: did the Employer prove the infraction by a preponderance of the evidence? And, if so, did it meet its burden of persuasion that “the punitive action being appealed is not an abuse of discretion.”


10 The Appellant brought forward a prior incident in the department in which an officer allegedly used excessive force on a suspect and received no discipline. The Appellant argued disparate treatment. The Hearing Office finds that insufficient evidence was in the record about the earlier incident to draw an apt comparison between it and the incident in the instant matter. The Appellant did not meet his burden of persuasion for disparate treatment. The Appellant also brought forward a prior incident involving a disagreement between him and Chief Hansen about the use of canines in the department. The Appellant alleges that animus by the police chief toward the Appellant resulting from this incident was a factor in the chief’s decision to terminate the Appellant. The undersigned hearing officer finds that the Appellant did not meet his burden of proof that this prior incident impacted the instant case.

17

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.