Documents › f2b3769d4e3df6a088e9097f582ca46c90a6d63a:1-20

Hearing Officer Recommendation - City of Brentwood - Paul Matejcek Appeal

POST board investigation reportagency investigation 2023-12-12 20 pages (file pages 1–20) original file
About this document
Layer
attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
Type as titled
hearing officer recommendation (kind from doc_type)
File
f2b3769d4e3df6a088e9097f582ca46c90a6d63a application/pdf
Cases
POST 2300017 · Paul Matejcek (filed under case)

About: Paul Matejcek (case)

Page 16 · file page 16 larger image
Image of page 16; its text is alongside
Text: OCR

Recommendation – City of Brentwood – Paul Matejcek Appeal: Paul D. Roose, Hearing Officer


“The Department presented no evidence,” the Appellant’s brief continues, “that Matejcek would not learn from this situation and therefore engage again in such conduct, or that he would not be amenable to further training for such situations. The Hearing Officer should thus find that a consideration of the Skelly factors leads to the conclusion that termination is unwarranted and excessive.”

The brief concludes as follows: “For the foregoing reasons, it is respectfully requested that the Hearing Officer find that Matejcek’s use of force against [V] was reasonable, and thus not a violation of Department policy. In the alternative, if the Hearing Officer finds that the use of force was not within policy, he should conclude that termination in these circumstances is unwarranted.”

DISCUSSION

The Appellant Violated Department Policy by Using Excessive Force on April 23, 2022: The preponderance of the evidence is that the Appellant engaged in an unauthorized use of force in violation of department policy. His decision to kick / push the handcuffed civilian was not reasonable, for several reasons:

    1. The Appellant and Officers Franson and Flynn were standing several feet away from [V] when she stood up. He and his fellow officers were in no imminent danger when she stood up.
    1. Expert witness McCann, called by the Appellant, identified spitting as the only potential assaultive behavior available to [V] at that moment. Review of the BWC video indicates that the Appellant could have merely stepped back or turned to the side if [V] spat at him.
    1. Expert witness McCann also stated that the flight risk alone would not have justified the Appellant’s kick. The Appellant’s after-the-fact justification for his kick, that [V] posed a danger to other civilians in the area of Home Depot, does not ring true. The danger posed by [V] at that moment was speculative. Had she fled, the officers on scene would have had other options at their disposal to address her flight.
    1. Kicking a handcuffed suspect was not a tactic that had been included in the department’s training.
    1. The Appellant’s expressed concern about the potential of [V] spitting at him is undermined by his next actions captured on the video – he moved close to her and grabbed her arms from behind. This did not appear to be the actions of someone concerned about infectious spittle.
    1. The Appellant’s actions cannot be excused as a “split-second” decision made in a rapidly evolving set of circumstances. The Appellant was handcuffed and seated. The Appellant observed her begin to rock front to back as if she was trying to stand up. He had at least a minute to anticipate her attempting to stand up and decide how he

16

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.