Hearing Officer Recommendation - City of Brentwood - Paul Matejcek Appeal
About this document
- Layer
- attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
- Type as titled
- hearing officer recommendation (kind from doc_type)
- File
- f2b3769d4e3df6a088e9097f582ca46c90a6d63a application/pdf
- Cases
About: Paul Matejcek (case)
Recommendation – City of Brentwood – Paul Matejcek Appeal: Paul D. Roose, Hearing Officer
legitimate concerns for his safety and that of his fellow officers when [V1] resisted his orders to stay seated and attempted to rise to her feet. He used the least amount of force possible to keep [V1] at a distance, and ensured that his force would not result in injury to [V1] indeed, [V1] was neither injured by the kick nor displayed any signs of agitation afterwards,” the Appellant contends.
The Appellant credits the opinion of expert witness McCann, including his opinion that “whether a use of force was reasonable is not evaluated under the standard of whether the force was the least intrusive means available; in other words, the availability of less intrusive options does not make the force option chosen unreasonable.”
“The Hearing Officer,” Appellant’s brief contends, “should therefore align himself with the conclusion reached by McCann that Matejcek, based on his personal experience, reasonably concluded [V1] was going to become assaultive and, accordingly, Matejcek’s kick was reasonable and not excessive; indeed, it was the least intrusive means of force that could be used to ensure officer safety.”
In regard to Department Policy, Appellant asserts that Matejcek’s use of force was within policy. “The majority of these factors weigh in favor of Matejcek’s use of force: [V1] had, in the past, indicated she was infected with Medical Inf, making it very dangerous to the officers were she to spit at them; [V1] was intoxicated by alcohol, and most likely methamphetamine, as she usually was; Matejcek did not exhibit any hostile behavior toward [V1] while she was cooperating; [V1] had known mental health issues; [V1] became resistive and ignored Matejcek’s commands; neither the handcuffs nor the presence of three officers could keep [V1] from spitting; and Matejcek had extensive experience with [V1] and was thus familiar with her behaviors.”
Appellant argues that the penalty is inappropriate. “Even if, arguendo, the Hearing Officer concludes that Matejcek’s use of force was unreasonable, he should find that termination is excessive and unwarranted,” Appellant contends. “First, Matejcek used the least amount of force available to him, force that expert McCann categorized as not even rising to the level of ‘intermediate’ force. Second, officers are taught how to use kicks in the Academy, and POST materials provide that kicks to the mid-section are appropriate. Third, Matejcek utilized the force knowing that [V1] would not be injured as a result and, in fact, she was not. Fourth, the City presented no evidence that Matejcek had previously been disciplined for improper use of force or, indeed, any misconduct at all. The Hearing Officer should find that a first instance of use of unreasonable force that resulted in no injuries does not merit termination, the ultimate disciplinary measure.”
15
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.