Hearing Officer Recommendation - City of Brentwood - Paul Matejcek Appeal
About this document
- Layer
- attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
- Type as titled
- hearing officer recommendation (kind from doc_type)
- File
- f2b3769d4e3df6a088e9097f582ca46c90a6d63a application/pdf
- Cases
About: Paul Matejcek (case)
Recommendation – City of Brentwood – Paul Matejcek Appeal: Paul D. Roose, Hearing Officer
The City contends that the “City meets its burden if the evidence shows that Matejcek more likely than not engaged in this misconduct. The City’s discipline should not be overturned unless the City has abused its discretion. Courts instruct civil service commissions, arbitrators, and hearing bodies to give deference to the employer’s penalty decision considering such things as the employer’s administration of its own standards and rules. (See Kolender v. San Diego Civil Service Commission (2007) 149 Cal.App.4th 464, 471.) The fact that reasonable minds may differ regarding the penalty imposed supports a finding that the employer has acted within its discretion. (Ackerman v. State Personnel Board (1983) 145 Cal.App.3d 395, 401.)”
The Appellant’s “prior experience with [V1] and his knowledge of her reputation to resist arrest did not justify his conduct,” the City writes in its brief. “Matejcek may argue that since [V1] spat on CSO Alan Sheffield after her arrest, his kick was appropriate, because he thought she would spit at the officers and he wanted to keep his face far away from any potential spittle. This argument fails because it is speculative and the exact type of 20/20 hindsight analysis the Supreme Court forbids: Matejcek cannot use actions [V1] engaged in after his use of force to justify his claim that his use of force was necessary.”
“Retraining,” the city contends, “would not be sufficient based on these facts. As chief Hansen testified, he lost trust that Matejcek would make an appropriate decision in the future regarding when and how to use force. This use of force was so egregious that no amount of retraining would rectify Matejcek’s behavior, and termination is the only appropriate remedy.”
“Chief Hansen,” the Employer asserts, “believed that Matejcek showed no remorse for his actions, and he lost faith in Matejcek’s ability to appropriately use force in the future. For all of these reasons, Chief Hansen determined that termination was the only appropriate level of discipline in this matter. Chief Hansen’s termination of Matejcek was not an abuse of discretion and should be upheld.”
The Employer concludes by writing “For all of the reasons identified above, all of the evidence and testimony clearly shows that Matejcek violated policy when he kicked [V1] in violation of law and policy. Matejcek knew that this technique was not trained or authorized by the Brentwood Police Department. Nevertheless, Matejcek kicked [V1] without justification. As a result, the Department did not abuse its discretion in deciding to terminate him, and Matejcek’s termination should be upheld.”
APPELLANT’S POSITION
The Appellant argues that “Matejcek did not violate the Department’s Use of Force Policy.” The hearing officer should find that the Appellant “due to his many previous personal encounters with [V1] had
14
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.