Hearing Officer Recommendation - City of Brentwood - Paul Matejcek Appeal
About this document
- Layer
- attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
- Type as titled
- hearing officer recommendation (kind from doc_type)
- File
- f2b3769d4e3df6a088e9097f582ca46c90a6d63a application/pdf
- Cases
About: Paul Matejcek (case)
Recommendation – City of Brentwood – Paul Matecjek Appeal: Paul D. Roose, Hearing Officer
Former Chief Hansen testified that he chose the termination penalty because he could no longer trust the Appellant. He thought the City would be exposed to liability if the Appellant were still on the street. He specifically rejected the idea of retraining as a viable option. Notably, he did not state why he believed that an intermediate form of discipline, such as a time-off suspension, would not correct the Appellant's behavior.
Part of the discretion that must be exercised by a deciding official in this type of case is the consideration of mitigation. No evidence emerged that Chief Hansen considered mitigating factors. Strong mitigation exists in the instant matter, as follows:
-
- The Appellant had nearly five years of discipline-free service as a patrol officer for the department. A witness called by the Employer, Officer Franson, testified that he wanted to be assigned to the Appellant's team because "in my opinion [he was] a good officer, a competent officer, somebody I could trust to get my back if things went really bad." This praise is especially meaningful given that Officer Franson testified that he believed the Appellant used excessive force in April 2022. No one from the Department testified to the contrary.
-
- In unrebuted testimony, the Appellant stated that the department recruited him because of his strong performance at the police academy.
-
- Chief Hansen testified that he believed that █ could have been badly hurt or even killed from the Appellant's kick. Yet the evidence is that she was unharmed and not in need of medical care after the deployed tactic. The Chief implied that the Appellant was just lucky that greater injury did not occur. The undersigned hearing officer believes that, indeed, the Appellant was fortunate that █ was not injured. However, the Appellant also needs to be given some credit for striking █ in such a way as to minimize the risk of injury.
-
- The Appellant's actions can, in part, be justified by his extensive knowledge of the prior behavior and predilection of █. This was not a first-time encounter between an officer and a civilian. She had a long track record of erratic and assaultive behavior. The Appellant over-reacted on April 23, 2022, but his actions must be viewed in the context of his prior interactions with the civilian.
-
- The Appellant handled the post-incident interviews with candor and professionalism. From the viewpoint of the hearing officer, the Appellant was wrong in concluding that he did not use excessive force. But no evidence emerged that he in any way attempted to cover up the incident or enlist his fellow officers in a conspiracy to do so. The preponderance of the evidence is that the Appellant behaved like a trustworthy police officer during the post-incident assessment.
Excessive force actions by law enforcement personnel must be evaluated on a case-by-case basis. One size does not fit all when it comes to meting out discipline for these kinds of incidents. What best fits this incident is a lesser disciplinary action. Its characteristics – no injury to the civilian, suspect with a past history of resisting arrest, officer with a good track record and no priors, candid post-incident
18
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.