Documents › ee9d702905639628c9a7271797da1d967fd66f44:38-47

Los Angeles Port Police Closing Argument Brief - Macario Sanchez (File No. 55836)

Agency records investigation reportagency investigation 2024-11-12 Los Angeles Port Police Department 10 pages (file pages 38–47) original file
About this document
Layer
agency record: part of a file an agency produced
Type as titled
closing argument brief (kind from doc_type)
Produced as
los-angeles-port-police/IA20-009 Redacted for public release per 832.7.pdf
File
ee9d702905639628c9a7271797da1d967fd66f44 application/pdf
Cases
agency:C-529c48bac5 · Macario Sanchez (concern)
agency:C-b1a07fa34a · Macario Sanchez (record)

About: Macario Sanchez (case), Macario Sanchez (case)

Page 10 · file page 47 larger image
Image of page 10; its text is alongside
Text: OCR

1 and "off the job" violations. Thus the level of discipline is left to the discretion of the Department
2 based on the egregiousness of the conduct and whether the Department believes the employee's
3 behavior can be corrected.

4 Officer Sanchez's behavior cannot be corrected in a manner upon which the Department
5 can rely. As discussed above, abuse of alcohol is not a reasonable explanation or excuse for his
6 conduct. In addition, his lack of credibility with his lack of memory [REDACTED]

7 [REDACTED]

8 [REDACTED] does not favor progressive discipline.

9
10 CONCLUSION

11 It is respectfully urged that the Hearing Examiner report to the Board of Civil Service
12 Commissioners that the Harbor Department complied with Policy 33.1D and 33.1E.3, that the
13 evidence submitted in support of the charges is adequate, and that the grounds for termination are
14 sufficient. The termination of Officer Sanchez was just. Further, the Department urges the Hearing
15 Examiner to recommend to the Board of Civil Service Commissioners that they find the following:
16 (1) all of the charges are sufficient and sustained, or alternatively that some of the charges are
17 sufficient and sustained; and (2) the termination is sustained.

18
19 Dated: November 12, 2024

Respectfully Submitted,
OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY
Hydee Feldstein Soto, City Attorney
Steven Otera, General Counsel

20
21
22 By:
DEBORAH DORNY, Deputy City Attorney
Attorneys for the City of Los Angeles, Harbor Department

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.