Documents › ee9d702905639628c9a7271797da1d967fd66f44:38-47

Los Angeles Port Police Closing Argument Brief - Macario Sanchez (File No. 55836)

Agency records investigation reportagency investigation 2024-11-12 Los Angeles Port Police Department 10 pages (file pages 38–47) original file
About this document
Layer
agency record: part of a file an agency produced
Type as titled
closing argument brief (kind from doc_type)
Produced as
los-angeles-port-police/IA20-009 Redacted for public release per 832.7.pdf
File
ee9d702905639628c9a7271797da1d967fd66f44 application/pdf
Cases
agency:C-529c48bac5 · Macario Sanchez (concern)
agency:C-b1a07fa34a · Macario Sanchez (record)

About: Macario Sanchez (case), Macario Sanchez (case)

Page 9 · file page 46 larger image
Image of page 9; its text is alongside
Text: OCR

1 engaged in a cascade of conduct that epitomizes conduct unbecoming a police officer.

2
3 A. Termination Is the Appropriate Discipline

4 The facts of this case are not in dispute. ■ reported the rape to ■ the
5 LAPD knowing the outcome could affect her personally. Her statements were supported by text
6 messages and a medical examination conducted by a Sexual Abuse Response Team (SART) nurse.
7 Sanchez's claim that he blacked out and does not remember anything about the rape or the events
8 that occurred afterward are simply not credible, nor does this defense negate the fact that ■
9 ■ was seriously harmed. Sanchez's behavior reflects unfavorably upon him, the Port Police
10 Department and the City of Los Angeles.

11 These causes of action represent a first offense for Sanchez. Discharge from City service
12 falls within the discipline guidelines of the Personnel Department which are based on Civil Service
13 Commission Policy 33 which specifies that employees performing functions that require peace
14 officer status are required to conduct themselves (on and off duty) in a manner demonstrating
15 respect for the laws they are sworn to uphold and the people and property they are employed to
16 protect.

17
18 B. The circumstances of this case do not align with the policy of progressive
19 discipline

20 Section 33.1(A) of the Policies of the Personnel Department City of Los Angeles (Discipline
21 Policies) provides, "The primary goal of this disciplinary policy is to correct employee behavior or
22 performance." This policy assumes that an employee's behavior can be corrected in a measurable
23 way upon which the Department can rely. The policy, however, concedes, "Some infractions . . .
24 may require proceeding directly to more severe levels of discipline." [Discipline Policies, section
25 33.1(E).] Accordingly, the discipline recommendations include discharge even as a first offense.
26 Under Section 33.2, for example, all City employees may face discharge on a first offense for
27 "Engaging in illegal behavior or conduct in conflict with job duties on or off the job." [Emphasis
28 added.] Section 3.2's Standards of Conduct for Peace Officers allows for discharge for "off duty"

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.