Daly City Police Department Administrative Investigative Memorandum 24-04 (Officer Smithmatungol)
About this document
- Layer
- attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
- Type as titled
- ia investigative memorandum (kind from doc_type)
- File
- 96e06f72db3e5e151c1b7bea10db9029b892e6b3 application/pdf
- Cases
About: Kevin Smithmatungol (case)
he had not obtained the suspect's thumbprint. Officer Smithmatungol said he had actually obtained it. He explained he had attempted to use his citation writer to obtain the print, but that it was not working. I told Officer Smithmatungol we had reviewed the BWC, which showed he was using a citation writer without the fingerprint option. He responded something to the effect of, "Oh, I must have forgot." He continued explaining how he had obtained it.
At the conclusion of the detention, he said he walked with the suspect to his patrol vehicle, where he printed a duplicate copy of the citation. He retrieved an ink pad and fingerprinted the suspect. He had her place her thumb on the back of the citation, and that was how he obtained her fingerprint. Officer Smithmatungol said he turned the hard copy citation in at the end of his shift by placing it on the sergeant's desk. Sgt. Tualaulelei had collected the paperwork at the end of the shift and said he did not recall seeing it. I had Officer Smithmatungol's report open on the computer while we were speaking with him. I reviewed the attachments to the case, but did not see it, which I shared with Officer Smithmatungol. He offered that it might still be in his duty bag, or might have been given to Officer Rodriguez, who was acting as his cover officer. We asked Officer Smithmatungol if he was sure he obtained the thumbprint. Without missing a beat he nodded his head and said "Yes."
Officer Smithmatungol then asked what would happen if he couldn't find the citation. Sgt. Tualaulelei said something to the effect of "I'm not calling you out, but I am calling you out. Are you sure you got the thumbprint?" Officer Smithmatungol again reiterated that he had obtained it, and again said the copy might be in his duty bag. Sgt. Tualaulelei said if he hadn't actually obtained it, now was the time to own up to it.
Officer Smithmatungol again said he had obtained it and would check his duty bag. I asked him to go check his duty bag now, and to let us know whether he had found it. About twenty minutes later, I saw Officer Smithmatungol in the in-coming squad room typing on the computer, and I asked if he had any luck locating it.
He had several printed out tickets in front of him, and picked them up to show them to me. He said he had located all of them in his duty bag, but was unable to locate the citation in question. He said he had texted Officer Rodriguez to ask if he had the citation. I asked Officer Smithmatungol to let me know if Officer Rodriguez located it, and he said he would. For the remainder of the shift, Officer Smithmatungol did not bring up the citation again, and neither Sgt. Tualaulelei nor I asked him about it any further.
At this point, I suspected Officer Smithmatungol was not being honest. On Sunday, 06/09/2024, I responded to Target and obtained additional security footage of Officer Smithmatungol's time at the scene. I reviewed several different camera angles, from the point of when Officer Smithmatungol arrived at Target, to the point he left and drove out of the mall onto Serramonte Blvd. I saw that once the suspect had been released from the loss prevention office at 2007 hrs., she immediately exited Target through the southern most front door, and walked east through the parking lot, out of view of the camera. She is not seen again.
Officer Smithmatungol briefly left the loss prevention office, and walked into Target, in the opposite direction of the suspect. He returned to the office about 25 seconds later, and remained
3 | Page
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.