Notice of Motion and Motion to Reopen Detention Hearing and Reconsider Detention (Andy Li, Case No. CR 14-196 CRB)
About this document
- Layer
- attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
- Type as titled
- superior court motion (kind from doc_type)
- File
- 24fc32bd9d66a04bd8e9605557bf3f291a70c2a0 application/pdf
- Cases
About: Michael Kim (case)
Case3:14-cr-00196-CRB Document410 Filed08/06/14 Page12 of 18
1 the recordings clearly indicate that Mr. Li made these statements as jokes, with other conversation
2 participants laughing, contributed their own ideas, and repeating Mr. Li's jokes amongst themselves.
3 1D233.20130329.1810 (2 of 2) at 00:25:40. Thus, the government mischaracterized Mr. Li's
4 statements and took them out of context in an attempt to convince the court that Mr. Li uttered these
5 statements seriously.
6 Perhaps the most telling indication that Mr. Li made these statements in jest is the fact that
7 they remained merely statements. Although the government recorded conversations with Mr. Li for
8 more than two years, he never followed up these statements with any action. The government has not
9 charged him with any crimes related to these colorful conversations. Indeed, the undercover agent
10 appears never to have solicited Mr. Li in any proposed violent crime, in contrast to some of Mr. Li's
11 codefendants, most likely because the undercover realized that such an attempt was not a fruitful
12 investigatory avenue. While Mr. Li's comments may reflect a vivid imagination and a dark sense of
13 humor, these traits are quite common and do not amount to criminal or dangerous conduct. Mere
14 statements, made in jest, are not chargeable offenses and do not demonstrate that Mr. Li is a danger to
15 the community. In fact, the government effectively conceded that these comments did not warrant
16 detention and that they did not believe Mr. Li intended to act on these statements by allowing Mr. Li
17 to roam free for one to two years after uttering these statements. Thus, when placed in context
18 through the recorded evidence, Mr. Li's discussions of "violent acts" followed by no action do not
19 support a finding that Mr. Li is a danger to the community.
20 The government also claimed that Mr. Li "discussed doing collections through use of physical
21 harm and intimidation.... indicat[ing] he did that with Mr. Chanthavong, and that they would use a
22 good guy/bad guy routine, and when Li gave a signal, Chanthavong would slap the person." Tr. at
23 7:10-15. However, the recording that corresponds to this conversation undermines this claim. First, it
24 is barely audible and does not serve to confirm Mr. Li's supposed statements. Second, to the extent
25 that it is audible, Mr. Li offers to help the undercover agent retrieve money owed to him, advising the
26 undercover agent, "You've just gotta be nice." 1D207.20130123.1335 at 01:13:43. The undercover
27 agent asks, "I assume you're the good guy?" Mr. Li replies, "Yeah. I'm good at negotiating." Id.
28 There is no audible mention whatsoever of Mr. Li committing physical harm or using intimidation. In
Gibson, Dunn &
Crutcher LLP9MOTION TO REOPEN DETENTION HEARING AND RECONSIDER DETENTION – CASE NO. CR 14-196 CRB
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.