Notice of Motion and Motion to Reopen Detention Hearing and Reconsider Detention (Andy Li, Case No. CR 14-196 CRB)
About this document
- Layer
- attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
- Type as titled
- superior court motion (kind from doc_type)
- File
- 24fc32bd9d66a04bd8e9605557bf3f291a70c2a0 application/pdf
- Cases
About: Michael Kim (case)
Case3:14-cr-00196-CRB Document410 Filed08/06/14 Page11 of 18
1 3. The Government Provided No Context for Mr. Li's Discussion of "Violent Acts."
2 Putting aside the fact that the government pointed only to discussions – and not acts of
3 violence – in an attempt to paint Mr. Li as a dangerous person, and that Mr. Li had no knowledge of
4 allegations related to these discussions prior to his detention hearing, a review of recordings from the
5 government's May 12, 2014 production demonstrates that in many instances, the government took
6 Mr. Li's allegedly "violent" statements out of context. The government based the information it
7 presented at Mr. Li's detention hearing mainly on an undercover agent's summary of a lengthy,
8 raucous dinner party attended by undercover agents, Mr. Li, and many others. Powell Decl., attached
9 hereto as Exhibit F, ¶ 3, Ex. 1. After the dinner party, Mr. Li, the undercover agents, and others
10 continued the revelry at a hotel bar. The government further relied on summaries of five shorter
11 conversations between undercover agents, Mr. Li, and others that also took place in social
12 environments, either at nightclubs or restaurants. The recordings of these conversations, not available
13 to Mr. Li until May 16, 2014, demonstrate that most of Mr. Li's comments were merely tough talk or
14 exaggerated tales from his younger days incited by the undercover agents' sharing stories of a similar
15 nature. In general, the tone of these crowded dinners and nights out was festive and dominated by
16 laughter. The recorded participants regaled each other with stories of past ordeals and triumphs,
17 attempting to "one-up" each other with descriptions of their outlandish (and exaggerated) feats. It was
18 in this context and in these environments that Mr. Li made supposedly "violent" comments to the
19 undercover agents and others. In fact, Mr. Li and others explicitly state on various occasions that the
20 supposed "violent" talk amounted to no more than a trading of stories. For example, in the segment of
21 the recordings where Mr. Li is allegedly discussing different ways to "inflict pain," the conversation
22 participants laugh repeatedly, indicating that this was not a serious discussion. Someone mentions
23 that they are "trad[ing] stories," in a lighthearted tone, and other individuals state, "Oh, to be young
24 again," and "[w]e're gonna be doing this all night" while breaking out in laughter, referring to the
25 facetious musings. Someone later acknowledges outright, "No, we're just talking... stories," and
26 later, "we're just trading stories... just stories." See 1D233.20130329.1810 (1 of 2) at 03:03:00 to
27 03:07:00. Similarly, regarding the government's claim that Mr. Li "discussed the best holidays on
28 which . . . you could kill someone," citing Halloween, the 4th of July, or Christmas (Tr. at 8:20-25),
Gibson, Dunn &
Crutcher LLP8MOTION TO REOPEN DETENTION HEARING AND RECONSIDER DETENTION – CASE NO. CR 14-196 CRB
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.