Cases › board:POST2410050

POST case 2410050

POST board · board proceeding · Michael Kim · San Francisco County Sheriff's Office
Case id
POST2410050
POST number
2410050
Incident dates
2000 – 2014-08-19 (4 incidents)
Category
dishonesty
POST outcome
revocation at posaab, 2025-10-09

Summary model-written

Michael Kim lied to a federal court and FBI agents to assist a friend in a criminal case, leading to a federal conviction for contempt of court. The Division found clear and convincing evidence of dishonesty, and the POSAAB recommended the revocation of his certification.

Officer

Name
Michael Kim
POST ID
A63-W93 (id)
Name in NPI
MICHAEL SHERMAN KIM

Search within this case's documents →

Proceedings 8

Extracted and classified by a model, quote is verbatim from source text

  1. 2024-12-23
    division
    assigned to conduct an investigation of serious misconduct
    source · quote found
    On December 23, 2024, I was assigned to conduct an investigation of serious misconduct.
    page 354
  2. 2025-01-23
    division
    received a report from an anonymous member of the public
    source · quote found
    On January 23, 2025, POST received a report from an anonymous member of the public that Respondent resigned from his deputy position based on his conviction
    page 357
  3. 2025-05-02
    division
    served Investigative Summary and Findings and accompanying Notice of Intent to Revoke
    Certification: revocation
    source · quote found
    Respondent was served with the Division's Investigative Summary and Findings and accompanying Notice of Intent to Revoke, notifying Respondent that the Division had found reasonable grounds for revocation of Respondent's POST certification, on May 2, 2025.
    page 2216
  4. 2025-05-27
    respondent
    requested a review of the Division's determination and reasons for revocation
    source · quote found
    Respondent requested a review of the Division's determination and reasons for revocation of Respondent's POST certification on May 27, 2025
    page 2216
  5. 2025-06-25
    division
    interviewed Respondent
    source · quote found
    On June 25, 2025, I interviewed Respondent.
    page 584
  6. 2025-07-02
    division
    found reasonable grounds for revocation or suspension
    Certification: revocation
    source · quote found
    Reasonable grounds exist to submit this case to the Peace Officer Standards Accountability Advisory Board and the POST Commission for consideration of revocation or suspension of Respondent’s peace officer certificates
    page 586
  7. 2025-10-09
    posaab
    held hearing
    source · quote found
    the Board scheduled the case for a hearing which was held on October 9, 2025.
    page 2216
  8. 2025-10-09
    posaab
    recommended revocation
    Certification: revocation · vote seven ayes
    source · quote found
    MEMBER DOYLE: Motion to decertify. CHAIRPERSON DUDLEY: Okay. Is there a second? MEMBER GLASER: Second.
    page 2289

Incidents 4

DateConductCategoryFindingDiscipline / outcome
— falsified a memo wrote to his supervisor, Chief Deputy Matthew Freeman, which repeated the lies he told FBI Special Agents dishonesty unknown
Division: substantiated
—
Evidence · quote found
Respondent stated that he made materially false statements in a memorandum he submitted to then-Chief Deputy Matthew Freeman, SFSO, which repeated the lies he told FBI Special Agents.
2000 used excessive force when Respondent placed his hands on an inmate’s neck — sustained placed Respondent on unpaid leave in 2000 for 10 days and extended his probationary period by one year
Evidence · quote found
the San Francisco Sheriff’s Office placed Respondent on unpaid leave in 2000 for 10 days and extended his probationary period by one year as a result of finding that he used excessive force when Respondent placed his hands on an inmate’s neck.
2014-08-06 signed a Declaration in Support of Defendant Andy Li’s Motion to Reopen Detention Hearing and Reconsider Detention under penalty of perjury containing several factual statements that were material to defendant Andy Li's motion and were materially false
Charges: 18 U.S.C. Section 401(1), a misdemeanor Contempt of Court charge → pled guilty in federal court to a violation of 18 U.S.C. Section 401(1), a misdemeanor; sentenced to three years of probation and a fine of $30,000
dishonesty unknown
Division: clear and convincing evidence substantiated that Respondent’s Declaration contained materially false statements, that he knowingly and willfully lied to a federal court, and that he obstructed justice in a federal criminal case through his lies
—
Evidence · quote found
On August 6, 2014, Respondent signed a Declaration with the United States District Court for the Northern District of California. . . Respondent signed the Declaration “under penalty of perjury under the laws of the State of California” as being “true and correct.”
2014-08-19 told FBI Special Agents during an interview that he did not know that Andy Li had a ballistic vest, that he dropped off a work-issued ballistic vest with his wife... and that he tried to get the vest back but forgot about the vest over time; these statements were materially false dishonesty unknown
Division: clear and convincing evidence substantiated that Respondent’s statements to FBI Special Agents were materially false
—
Evidence · quote found
The clear and convincing evidence substantiated that Respondent’s statements to FBI Special Agents were materially false. The clear and convincing evidence further substantiated that Kim’s statements violated California Penal Code Section 13510.8(b)(1) and POST Regulation 1205(a)(1)

Documents 149

agency investigation 32

DocumentKindDatePagesSourceLinked by
FBI FD-302 Report - Undercover Purchase from Kongphet Chanthavong interview summary 2012-09-26 1 Board filed under case
FBI FD-302 Report of Undercover Operation 03/29/2013 interview summary 2013-06-24 5 Board filed under case
FBI Interview of San Francisco Sheriff's Office Deputy Michael Sherman Kim interview transcript 2014-08-20 4 Board filed under case
FBI Interview of Michael Kim interview transcript 2014-12-22 7 Board filed under case
San Francisco County Sheriff's Office Archived Triage Report - Michael Kim investigation report 2023-06-27 2 Board filed under case
POST Interview of Tiffany Martin interview transcript 2025-03-11 3 Board filed under case
POST Interview of Ronnie Wan regarding Michael Kim interview transcript 2025-03-11 4 Board filed under case
POST Report of Interview of Mel Fonthal interview transcript 2025-04-16 4 Board filed under case
POST Administrative Interview Transcript of Dr. Ryan Dunnigan interview transcript 2025-06-25 32 Board filed under case
POST Administrative Interview Transcript of Michael Kim interview transcript 2025-06-25 83 Board filed under case
POST Interview Summary of Michael Kim interview transcript 2025-06-25 5 Board filed under case
POST Interview Summary of Ryan Dunnigan interview summary 2025-06-25 3 Board filed under case
Supplement to Investigative Summary and Findings - Michael Kim investigation report 2025-07-02 4 Board filed under case
594 - BR05_POST2410050_D_Interview_of_Michael_Kim_12_22_2014b_Redacted.pdf interview transcript 2025-10-09 7 Board packet item
594 - BR15_POST2410050_N_Wan-ROI_Redacted.pdf investigation report 2025-10-09 4 Board packet item
594 - BR16_POST2410050_O_Fonthal_Final_ROI_Redacted.pdf investigation report 2025-10-09 4 Board packet item
594 - BR18_POST2410050_Q_Martin_ROI_Redacted.pdf investigation report 2025-10-09 3 Board packet item
594 - BR20_POST2410050_S_Interview_of_San_Francisco_Sheriff_s_Office_Deputy_Michael_Sherman_Kim_Redacted.pdf interview transcript 2025-10-09 4 Board packet item
594 - BR28_POST2410050_Michael Kim 6.25.2025 POST interview transcript_Redacted.pdf interview transcript 2025-10-09 83 Board packet item
594 - BR29_POST2410050_Ryan Dunnigan 6.25.2025 POST interview transcript.pdf interview transcript 2025-10-09 32 Board packet item
594 - BR30_POST2410050_Kim_Final report of POST interview.pdf interview transcript 2025-10-09 5 Board packet item
594 - BR31_POST2410050_Dunnigan_Final Report of POST interview interview transcript 2025-10-09 3 Board packet item
648 - BR05_POST2410050_D_Interview_of_Michael_Kim_12_22_2014b_Redacted.pdf interview transcript 2025-12-02 7 Board packet item
648 - BR15_POST2410050_N_Wan-ROI_Redacted.pdf investigation report 2025-12-02 4 Board packet item
648 - BR16_POST2410050_O_Fonthal_Final_ROI_Redacted.pdf investigation report 2025-12-02 4 Board packet item
648 - BR18_POST2410050_Q_Martin_ROI_Redacted.pdf investigation report 2025-12-02 3 Board packet item
648 - BR20_POST2410050_S_Interview_of_San_Francisco_Sheriff_s_Office_Deputy_Michael_Sherman_Kim_Redacted.pdf interview transcript 2025-12-02 4 Board packet item
648 - BR28_POST2410050_Michael Kim 6.25.2025 POST interview transcript_Redacted.pdf interview transcript 2025-12-02 83 Board packet item
648 - BR29_POST2410050_Ryan Dunnigan 6.25.2025 POST interview transcript.pdf interview transcript 2025-12-02 32 Board packet item
648 - BR30_POST2410050_Kim_Final report of POST interview.pdf interview transcript 2025-12-02 5 Board packet item
648 - BR31_POST2410050_Dunnigan_Final Report of POST interview interview transcript 2025-12-02 3 Board packet item
San Francisco County Sheriff's Office Background Investigation Summary - Michael Kim investigation report — 1 Board filed under case

board proceeding 18

DocumentKindDatePagesSourceLinked by
POST Executive Review & Peace Officer Standards Accountability Division Recommendation - Michael Kim (POST2410050) executive review 2025-04-17 2 Board filed under case
Investigative Summary and Findings: Michael Kim (POST2410050) investigative summary 2025-05-02 27 Board filed under case
594 - Cover Page agenda item report 2025-10-09 3 Board packet item
594 - BR01_POST2410050_Kim_Michael_ISF.pdf investigative summary 2025-10-09 27 Board packet item
594 - BR02_POST2410050_A_Kim_Michael_ExecReviewDivisionRec.pdf executive review 2025-10-09 2 Board packet item
594 - BR24_POST2410050_Michael Kim_Supplement ISF 07 02 2025.pdf investigative summary 2025-10-09 4 Board packet item
POSAAB Agenda Item Report - Michael Kim (POST2410050) agenda item report 2025-10-09 3 Board filed under case
POSAAB Agenda Item Report - Michael Kim (POST2410050) agenda item report 2025-10-09 3 Board filed under case
POSAAB Board Recommendation re: Peace Officer Certification of Michael Kim board recommendation 2025-10-09 3 Board filed under case
POSAAB Meeting Transcript October 9, 2025 hearing transcript 2025-10-09 74 Board filed under case
Agenda Item Report POST2410050 - Michael Kim agenda item report 2025-10-30 4 Board filed under case
648 - Cover Page agenda item report 2025-12-02 4 Board packet item
648 - BR01_POST2410050_Kim_Michael_ISF.pdf investigative summary 2025-12-02 27 Board packet item
648 - BR02_POST2410050_A_Kim_Michael_ExecReviewDivisionRec.pdf executive review 2025-12-02 2 Board packet item
648 - BR24_POST2410050_Michael Kim_Supplement ISF 07 02 2025.pdf investigative summary 2025-12-02 4 Board packet item
648 - POST2410050_Kim_Michael_October_2025_POSAAB_Agenda_Record.pdf posaab agenda record 2025-12-02 6 Board packet item
648 - POST2410050_Kim_Michael_Board_Recommendation_Signed.pdf board recommendation 2025-12-02 3 Board packet item
648 - POST2410050_Kim_Michael_Transcript_Board_10.09.2025.pdf hearing transcript 2025-12-02 74 Board packet item

correspondence and logs 8

DocumentKindDatePagesSourceLinked by
Document Properties for Michael Kim Letter of Recommendation (Miyamoto) correspondence 2016-02-10 1 Board filed under case
Document Properties for Mike Kim Letter 2024 (Author: Paul Miyamoto) correspondence 2024-02-15 1 Board filed under case
594 - BR27_POST2410050_M. Kim letter 2024_Sheriff Miyamoto_Redacted.pdf correspondence 2025-10-09 1 Board packet item
594 - BR34_POST2410050_scrnshot properties of letter (1) from Miyamoto.pdf correspondence 2025-10-09 1 Board packet item
594 - BR35_POST2410050_scrnshot properties of letter (2) from miyamoto.pdf correspondence 2025-10-09 1 Board packet item
648 - BR27_POST2410050_M. Kim letter 2024_Sheriff Miyamoto_Redacted.pdf correspondence 2025-12-02 1 Board packet item
648 - BR34_POST2410050_scrnshot properties of letter (1) from Miyamoto.pdf correspondence 2025-12-02 1 Board packet item
648 - BR35_POST2410050_scrnshot properties of letter (2) from miyamoto.pdf correspondence 2025-12-02 1 Board packet item

criminal case 49

DocumentKindDatePagesSourceLinked by
California Highway Patrol Traffic Collision Report 2012110250 police report 2012-11-30 10 Board filed under case
Character Letter for Andy Li from Evins Li court record 2013-07-29 1 Board filed under case
US District Court Detention Hearing Transcript - Andy M. Li court record 2014-04-08 19 Board filed under case
US District Court Northern District of California Order of Detention (Defendant Andy Li) court record 2014-05-07 3 Board filed under case
US District Court Northern District of California Order of Detention Pending Trial (Andy Li) court record 2014-05-07 3 Board filed under case
Character Letter from Richard Li regarding Andy Li court record 2014-07-09 1 Board filed under case
US District Court Northern District of California Order Denying Motion to Revoke Detention Order (Defendant Brandon Jackson) court record 2014-07-23 4 Board filed under case
Declaration of Joanna L. Powell in Support of Defendant Andy Li's Motion to Reopen Detention Hearing court record 2014-08-04 2 Board filed under case
Declaration of Vanessa A. Pastora in Support of Defendant Andy Li's Motion to Reopen Detention Hearing court record 2014-08-05 3 Board filed under case
Declaration of Mimi Li in Support of Defendant Andy Li's Motion to Reopen Detention Hearing court record 2014-08-05 4 Board filed under case
Declaration of Mimi Li in Support of Defendant Andy Li's Motion to Reopen Detention Hearing court record 2014-08-05 4 Board filed under case
Notice of Motion and Motion to Reopen Detention Hearing and Reconsider Detention (Andy Li, Case No. CR 14-196 CRB) court record 2014-08-06 18 Board filed under case
Declaration of Michael Kim in Support of Defendant Andy Li's Motion to Reopen Detention Hearing court record 2014-08-06 2 Board filed under case
US District Court Northern District of California [Proposed] Order Granting Motion to Reopen Detention Hearing (Case CR 14-196 CRB) court record 2014-08-06 2 Board filed under case
Declaration of Michael Kim in Support of Defendant Andy Li's Motion to Reopen Detention Hearing court record 2014-08-06 2 Board filed under case
United States' Opposition to Defendant Li's Motion to Reconsider Detention Order court record 2014-08-22 13 Board filed under case
US District Court Northern District of California Minute Order USA v. Andy Li (14-cr-00196-CRB) court record 2014-09-05 1 Board filed under case
U.S. District Court Northern District of California Defendant Information Michael Kim (Case 3:18-cr-00124-JCS) court record 2018-03-27 1 Board filed under case
US District Court Northern District of California Information v. Michael Kim (Case 3:18-cr-00124-JCS) court record 2018-03-27 2 Board filed under case
US District Court Northern District of California Criminal Cover Sheet USA v. Michael Kim (Case 3:18-cr-00124-JCS) court record 2018-03-27 1 Board filed under case
USA v. Michael Kim Plea Agreement (Case 3:18-cr-00124-JCS) court record 2018-05-25 6 Board filed under case
Defendant Michael Kim's Memorandum in Aid of Sentencing (Case 3:18-cr-00124-JCS) court record 2018-10-05 6 Board filed under case
US District Court Northern District of California Judgment in Criminal Case: Michael Kim (CR-18-00124-001 JCS) court record 2018-10-15 6 Board filed under case
US District Court Northern District of California Request and Order for Early Termination of Supervision (Michael Kim, Case 3:18-cr-00124) court record 2020-11-02 3 Board filed under case
594 - BR04_POST2410050_C_US_Opp_to_Li_Motion_to_Reconsider_Detention_Order_Redacted.pdf court record 2025-10-09 23 Board packet item
594 - BR06_POST2410050_E_Order_of_Detention_Pending_Trial_Redacted.pdf court record 2025-10-09 3 Board packet item
594 - BR07_POST2410050_F_Notice_of_Motion_and_Motion_to_Reopen_Detention_Hearing_and_Reconsider_Detention_Redacted.pdf court record 2025-10-09 75 Board packet item
594 - BR08_POST2410050_G_Declaration_of_Michael_Kim_Redacted.pdf court record 2025-10-09 2 Board packet item
594 - BR09_POST2410050_H_Declaration_of_Mimi_Li_Redacted.pdf court record 2025-10-09 4 Board packet item
594 - BR10_POST2410050_I_Minute_Order_Redacted.pdf court record 2025-10-09 1 Board packet item
594 - BR11_POST2410050_J_Information_Kim_Redacted.pdf court record 2025-10-09 4 Board packet item
594 - BR12_POST2410050_K_JUDGMENT_Redacted.pdf court record 2025-10-09 6 Board packet item
594 - BR13_POST2410050_L_US_DIS_CAND_3_18cr124_d10947289e796_Order_signed_11_2_2020_by_Chief_Magistrate_Judge_J_Redacted.pdf court record 2025-10-09 3 Board packet item
594 - BR21_POST2410050_T_0002_PLEA_AGREEMENT_v.1_Redacted.pdf court record 2025-10-09 6 Board packet item
594 - BR22_POST2410050_U_Defendants_Memorandum_in_Aid_of_Sentencing_Redacted.pdf court record 2025-10-09 20 Board packet item
594 - BR23_POST2410050_V_Redacted_Exhibit_C_to_Memo_in_Aid_of_Sentencing_Redacted.pdf court record 2025-10-09 9 Board packet item
648 - BR04_POST2410050_C_US_Opp_to_Li_Motion_to_Reconsider_Detention_Order_Redacted.pdf court record 2025-12-02 23 Board packet item
648 - BR06_POST2410050_E_Order_of_Detention_Pending_Trial_Redacted.pdf court record 2025-12-02 3 Board packet item
648 - BR07_POST2410050_F_Notice_of_Motion_and_Motion_to_Reopen_Detention_Hearing_and_Reconsider_Detention_Redacted.pdf court record 2025-12-02 75 Board packet item
648 - BR08_POST2410050_G_Declaration_of_Michael_Kim_Redacted.pdf court record 2025-12-02 2 Board packet item
648 - BR09_POST2410050_H_Declaration_of_Mimi_Li_Redacted.pdf court record 2025-12-02 4 Board packet item
648 - BR10_POST2410050_I_Minute_Order_Redacted.pdf court record 2025-12-02 1 Board packet item
648 - BR11_POST2410050_J_Information_Kim_Redacted.pdf court record 2025-12-02 4 Board packet item
648 - BR12_POST2410050_K_JUDGMENT_Redacted.pdf court record 2025-12-02 6 Board packet item
648 - BR13_POST2410050_L_US_DIS_CAND_3_18cr124_d10947289e796_Order_signed_11_2_2020_by_Chief_Magistrate_Judge_J_Redacted.pdf court record 2025-12-02 3 Board packet item
648 - BR21_POST2410050_T_0002_PLEA_AGREEMENT_v.1_Redacted.pdf court record 2025-12-02 6 Board packet item
648 - BR22_POST2410050_U_Defendants_Memorandum_in_Aid_of_Sentencing_Redacted.pdf court record 2025-12-02 20 Board packet item
648 - BR23_POST2410050_V_Redacted_Exhibit_C_to_Memo_in_Aid_of_Sentencing_Redacted.pdf court record 2025-12-02 9 Board packet item
San Francisco County Sheriff's Office Polygraph Examination Report - Michael Kim forensic report — 1 Board filed under case

discipline and employment 35

DocumentKindDatePagesSourceLinked by
San Francisco Sheriff's Department Mugshot Profile - Michael Kim personnel record 1996-05-24 2 Board filed under case
Character Reference Letter for Andy Li from Parole Agent Ken Wong character letter 2014-01-10 1 Board filed under case
Character Reference Letter for Andy Li from Ben Fandinola character letter 2014-05-06 1 Board filed under case
Letter of Support for Andy Li from Eddy Zheng character letter 2014-07-09 1 Board filed under case
Character Letter from Mimi Li regarding Andy Li character letter 2014-08-06 1 Board filed under case
Character Reference Letter from Helen Yoo-Lee and Frank Lee regarding Andy Li character letter 2014-08-06 1 Board filed under case
Character Reference Letter for Andy Li by Caesar Marabuto character letter 2014-08-06 1 Board filed under case
Character Reference Letter from Joseph Phong Chu for Andy Li character letter 2014-08-06 1 Board filed under case
Character Reference Letter from Jenny Santos regarding Andy Li character letter 2014-08-06 2 Board filed under case
Character Reference Letter from Jeff Lam to Judge Joseph C. Spero character letter 2018-07-03 2 Board filed under case
Character Reference Letter from Jeff Lam for Michael Kim character letter 2018-07-03 2 Board filed under case
Character Reference Letter for Michael Kim from Paul E. Rapicavoli character letter 2018-07-04 1 Board filed under case
Character Reference Letter for Michael Kim from Paul E. Rapicavoli character letter 2018-07-04 2 Board filed under case
Character Reference Letter from Les Pasamonte for Michael Kim character letter 2018-07-05 2 Board filed under case
Character Letter from Les Pasamonte regarding Michael Kim character letter 2018-07-05 2 Board filed under case
Character Reference Letter from Michelle G. Lam for Michael Kim character letter 2018-07-10 2 Board filed under case
Character Letter from Michelle G. Lam regarding Michael Kim character letter 2018-07-10 2 Board filed under case
Character Letter for Michael Kim from Matthew Lujan character letter 2018-07-24 2 Board filed under case
Character Letter for Michael Kim from Matthew Lujan character letter 2018-07-24 2 Board filed under case
San Francisco Police Department Record Clearance for Michael Kim personnel record 2018-10-03 2 Board filed under case
Character Reference Letter for Michael Kim from Sheriff Paul Miyamoto character letter 2024 1 Board filed under case
Dunnigan Psychological & Threat Assessments Secondary Psychological Pre-Employment Evaluation - Michael Kim personnel record 2024-03-13 3 Board filed under case
San Francisco County Sheriff's Office Employment Application and Background Approval - Michael Kim personnel record 2024-11-05 5 Board filed under case
POST Profile Report - Michael Kim personnel record 2025-04-30 4 Board filed under case
594 - BR03_POST2410050_B_Kim_Michael_POSTProfile.pdf personnel record 2025-10-09 4 Board packet item
594 - BR19_POST2410050_R_Letter_from_Paul_Miyamoto_to_To_Whom_It_May_Concern_Redacted.pdf character letter 2025-10-09 1 Board packet item
594 - BR25_POST2410050_FW from SO Counsel Masters_ Letters of rec from Paul Miyamoto_Redacted.pdf character letter 2025-10-09 2 Board packet item
594 - BR26_POST2410050_M. Kim LOR_Captain Miyamoto_Redacted.pdf character letter 2025-10-09 1 Board packet item
648 - BR03_POST2410050_B_Kim_Michael_POSTProfile.pdf personnel record 2025-12-02 4 Board packet item
648 - BR19_POST2410050_R_Letter_from_Paul_Miyamoto_to_To_Whom_It_May_Concern_Redacted.pdf character letter 2025-12-02 1 Board packet item
648 - BR25_POST2410050_FW from SO Counsel Masters_ Letters of rec from Paul Miyamoto_Redacted.pdf character letter 2025-12-02 2 Board packet item
648 - BR26_POST2410050_M. Kim LOR_Captain Miyamoto_Redacted.pdf character letter 2025-12-02 1 Board packet item
Letter of Recommendation for Michael Kim from Captain Paul Miyamoto character letter — 1 Board filed under case
Character Reference Letter from Sheriff Paul Miyamoto for Michael Kim character letter — 1 Board filed under case
San Francisco County Sheriff's Office Background Application and Personal History Statement of Michael Kim personnel record — 6 Board filed under case

evidence 7