Documents › 58590b04707e3895dcd810727eb33b7af4d3b69f:2205-2207

648 - BR31_POST2410050_Dunnigan_Final Report of POST interview

POST board interview transcriptagency investigation 2025-12-02 3 pages (file pages 2205–2207) original file
About this document
Layer
packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
Type as titled
case_attachment (kind from title)
File
58590b04707e3895dcd810727eb33b7af4d3b69f application/pdf
Cases
POST 2410050 · Michael Kim (packet item)

About: Michael Kim (case)

Page 1 · file page 2205 larger image
Image of page 1; its text is alongside
Text: digital text layer
STATE OF CALIFORNIA                                                                                                                                                                                  
   GAVIN NEWSOM, Governor 
 
DEPARTMENT OF JUSTICE 
ROB BONTA, Attorney General 
 
Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training 
860 Stillwater Road 
West Sacramento, CA 95605-1603 
www.post.ca.gov 
 
 
The mission of the California Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training is to continually enhance  
the professionalism of California law enforcement in serving its communities.  
 
 
On June 25, 2025, California Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training 
(“POST”) Law Enforcement Consultant Kevin Sherburne interviewed Ryan Dunnigan at his 
office in San Rafael, California.  Also present during the interview was Carrie Woolley, 
counsel for POST.  Communications by the parties during the interview were electronically 
recorded.  The recording will serve as the true and accurate record of the statements made 
by Dunnigan.  After being advised of the identity of the interviewer and the purpose of the 
interview, that being to obtain information related to allegations of serious misconduct, 
Dunnigan provided the following information: 
 
In November 2023, Dunnigan performed a secondary psychological evaluation of 
Michael Kim.  Kim was a candidate for a position with the San Francisco Sheriff’s Office 
and did not pass the initial evaluation.  He contacted Dunnigan for a secondary evaluation.  
San Francisco Sheriff’s Office provides the polygraph but not the initial evaluation to the 
secondary evaluator.  Dunnigan did not have a pre-existing relationship with Kim prior to 
Kim asking for a secondary evaluation in connection with employment.  Neither did Kim 
continue in any professional way with Dunnigan after the evaluation.  The only relationship 
Dunnigan had with Kim was with respect to the secondary evaluation for employment 
purposes. 
 
Dunnigan did not meet Kim in person.  He conducted the evaluation by Zoom.  
Dunnigan’s communications with San Francisco Sheriff’s Office were through their internal 
email system.  He likely reached out to Sergeant Mel Fonthal who was the usual point 
person.  After requesting records, it usually is about 3-5 days for Sergeant Fonthal to get 
him records.  After that, Dunnigan schedules the appointment with the candidate for 1-2 
weeks after that.  After making a finding of not suitable in November 2023, Dunnigan 
completed the paperwork and submitted it to Sergeant Fonthal or the lieutenant through 
their internal system.  They responded asking that he change one of the words.  Dunnigan 
used the words “correctional deputy,” and that is different than a deputy sheriff, so 
Sergeant Fonthal wanted the wording to reflect the position of deputy sheriff. 
 
Later, Kim asked if he could wait and postpone the finding of not suitable but that 
was not acceptable clinically.  Some of the information can become stale or other events 
could occur in the interim.  A couple of days is one thing but a couple of months is too long.  
Kim wanted Dunnigan to wait a couple of months.  So, Dunnigan submitted his finding of 
not suitable.  Kim’s position was that the Sheriff really wanted him to work there.  Dunnigan 
said that if the dust settles on this other investigation, then maybe I can re-evaluate you.  
Then, in approximately March 2024, Kim reached out for a re-evaluation.  No one else 
reached out to Dunnigan in the meantime. 
 
This case was very unusual.  Normally, a candidate has to wait a year before 
reapplying.  That was not the case for the San Francisco Sheriff’s Office.  If they want to do 
it, then it is not an ethical or clinical problem for Dunnigan. 
 
Shown a letter stating it was from Paul Miyamoto and addressed to To Whom It May 
Concern, Dunnigan stated he recognized it.  Dunnigan has only received maybe one or two 
2205

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.