United States' Opposition to Defendant Li's Motion to Reconsider Detention Order
About this document
- Layer
- attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
- Type as titled
- court filing (kind from doc_type)
- File
- 220c231d4769bb81422c9ea87f487a1926d6b49a application/pdf
- Cases
About: Michael Kim (case)
Case3:14-cr-00196-CRB Document462 Filed08/22/14 Page5 of 13
1 statement remains as true today as it was during the hearing on April 8, 2014.2
2 Of course, if government counsel had known on April 8, 2014 that the owner of the residence
3 had claimed ownership of the shotgun in the residence, that could have mitigated the shotgun and
4 government counsel would have provided that information to the Court. That information, however,
5 was not known to government counsel. The detention hearing took place shortly after the March 26,
6 2014 search of more than 30 locations by approximately 400 federal agents, interspersed with other
7 detention hearings, initial appearances, and grand jury sessions, and while a massive amount of evidence
8 was still being processed by the agents and being communicated to the case agents and, eventually, to
9 government counsel. That Mr. Walker claimed ownership of the shotgun was actually not known to
10 government counsel until after the defendant filed his current motion to reconsider the Court's detention
11 order. Shortly after the search of the defendant's residence, Mr. Walker did claim to two FBI agents and
12 one FBI employee – not an agent – that he was the owner of the shotgun. Unfortunately, that
13 information was not filtered through to the investigating FBI case agents until weeks after the hearing.
14 The first interview of Mr. Walker by a knowledgeable case agent was conducted on April 25, 2014, and
15 listed in an FBI 302 record of interview not seen by government counsel until after defendant's motion
16 was filed. The government concedes that the government, in the global sense, did have information that
17 Mr. Walker claimed to own the shotgun, but submits that for understandable reasons the information did
18 not reach the core trial team until after the hearing. Upon review of the full matter, however, the
19 information should not cause the Court to reconsider defendant's detention.
20 The nature of the information regarding Mr. Walker is far less important than defendant would
21 have the Court believe. First, the issue with a felon, narcotics manufacturer, and dealer like defendant
22 Li is not ownership of a firearm, it is possession of a firearm. See, e.g., 18 U.S.C. § 922(g) and 924(c)
23 (criminalizing possession of firearms, regardless of ownership). The government never described
24 defendant Li to the Court as the owner of the shotgun. What remains absolutely true is that defendant
25 undoubtedly had a shotgun in a residence that was under his dominion and control and, therefore, in his
26 possession regardless of who was the legal owner of the shotgun. Whether defendant knew of the
27
28 2 The only portion that turned out to be factually inaccurate is that there were only 81 marijuana plants, rather than 87 marijuana plants in the Lis' residence.
U.S. OPP. TO RECONSIDERATION
CR 14-0196 CRB
2
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.