POST Investigative Summary and Findings - Kevin Smithmatungol
About this document
- Layer
- attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
- Type as titled
- investigative summary (kind from doc_type)
- File
- fe284367319ff6cda513fce9e89da9a28955a9d9 application/pdf
- Cases
About: Kevin Smithmatungol (case)
3. October 25, 2024 (Subpoenas)
Based on the following clear and convincing evidence, it is highly probable the Respondent's statements during his Internal Affairs interview were dishonest when he stated that he attempted to serve two subpoenas that had been assigned to him:
- • A review of the Respondent's Computer Aided Dispatch (CAD) history and BWC confirmed he was on scene for a separate call of service at the time he indicated the first service attempt was made at 2123 hours.75
- • A review of the Respondent's CAD history and BWC confirmed there were no calls for service generated and BWC activations related to subpoena service attempts.76
- • The Respondent's Axon ALPR data indicated his patrol vehicle never traveled on the street of the first subpoena [REDACTED].77
- • The Respondent's Axon ALPR data indicated his patrol vehicle drove past the residence of the second subpoena [REDACTED] twice during his shift. The Respondent made an enforcement stop across the street from the residence of the second subpoena, but BWC confirmed he never went to the residence.78
- • Nest Camera footage from a neighboring residence near [REDACTED] indicated a patrol vehicle never traveled to the residence on October 25, 2024, between 2130 and 2200 hours.79
- • A resident from the residence in the first subpoena [REDACTED] indicated he and his family were home during the day and night of October 25, 2024, no one came to their home to attempt to serve a subpoena.80
- • At the end of his Internal Affairs interview, the Respondent stated, "I don't, I don't want to give you all these excuses, but if there's no video of me doing it, then I, maybe I didn't do it. And I don't know why these dates and times would be on there, but I, I don't remember honestly."81
- • During the interview with the Division, the Respondent admitted he never attempted to serve either subpoena.
- • During the interview with the Division, the Respondent explained, for the first subpoena, he wrote on the subpoena return slip that he attempted to serve it when had not because, "In all honesty, I didn't want to get in trouble. Um, it's plain and simple." The Respondent further explained DCPD officers were told they had to make an attempt for a subpoena, that no attempt was not acceptable,
75 Attachment G – Administrative Investigative Memorandum Excerpts (24-07) – page 2 and pages 5-6.
76 Attachment G – Administrative Investigative Memorandum Excerpts (24-07) – page 2, and pages 5-6.
77 Attachment G – Administrative Investigative Memorandum Excerpts (24-07) – pages 6-9.
78 Attachment G – Administrative Investigative Memorandum Excerpts (24-07) – pages 5-9.
79 Attachment G – Administrative Investigative Memorandum Excerpts (24-07) – page 3 and page 8.
80 Attachment G – Administrative Investigative Memorandum Excerpts (24-07) – pages 2-3.
81 Attachment H – Administrative Interview Transcript (24-07) – page 13, lines 24-26.
Investigative Summary and Recommendation
Kevin Smithmatungol
Case Number
POST2505112/POST2505137/POST2505140
Page 20
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.