POST Investigative Summary and Findings - Kevin Smithmatungol
About this document
- Layer
- attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
- Type as titled
- investigative summary (kind from doc_type)
- File
- fe284367319ff6cda513fce9e89da9a28955a9d9 application/pdf
- Cases
About: Kevin Smithmatungol (case)
asked to explain why he indicated it should rather than it will, the Respondent stated, “I can’t explain. Um, it will.”46
- • When asked, “Is there any clarity that you can give me as to why I’m not showing your vehicle at these locations?” the Respondent stated, “I genuinely don’t remember serving the subpoenas. Okay. That’s why I wanted to see the calls from that day ‘cause I wanted to narrow down that happened that day. I generally don’t remember.”47
- • When asked, “So if there’s no evidence of you doing it, then you didn’t do it?” and the Respondent stated, “If there’s not, then there’s not.”48
- • The Respondent stated, “I don’t, I don’t want to give you all these excuses, but if there’s no video of me doing it, then I, maybe I didn’t do it. And I don’t know why these dates and times would be on there, but I, I don’t remember honestly.”49
- • When asked, “Um, at this point, I just have one last question and is, did you willfully write times and dates on there with the intent to deceive in any way, um, and state something on that paperwork that you knew to be not true?” and the Respondent stated, “I don’t. I just, I wrote it on here. I, this is my handwriting. I wrote it. Yep. But I don’t, I can’t recall why I wrote it.”50
On January 13, 2026, the Respondent was interviewed by POST LEC Christina Moore and LEC Kevin Sherburne and made the following statements:51
- • He estimated, throughout his career, he has attempted to serve 100 subpoenas, and of those, has successfully served a couple dozen.
- • On October 25, 2024, he was assigned two (2) subpoenas to serve during his shift.
- • He did not personally know either of the intended recipients of either subpoena.
- • He did not attempt to serve either subpoena.
- • He gave the subpoena return slip to his sergeant after indicating he attempted to serve each subpoena at 2123 hours and 2142 hours respectively.
- • He had no evidence to refute the following evidence presented to him: CAD history, BWC, APLR data, Nest camera footage, and a witness interview.
- • When asked why he indicated on the subpoena return slip that he had attempted to serve the subpoena on [REDACTED] when he had not, he stated, “In all honesty, I didn’t want to get in trouble. Um, it’s plain and simple.”52
46 Attachment H – Administrative Interview Transcript (24-07) – page 8, line 49 – page 9, line 3.
47 Attachment H – Administrative Interview Transcript (24-07) – page 11, lines 35-40.
48 Attachment H – Administrative Interview Transcript (24-07) – page 13, lines 4-9.
49 Attachment H – Administrative Interview Transcript (24-07) – page 13, lines 24-26.
50 Attachment H – Administrative Interview Transcript (24-07) – page 14, lines 1-6.
51 Attachment K – Division Interview Transcript.
52 Attachment K – Division Interview Transcript – page 32, line 36.
Investigative Summary and Recommendation
Kevin Smithmatungol
Case Number
POST2505112/POST2505137/POST2505140
Page 14
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.