Riverside Police Department Administrative Investigation PA2211047 / Hostile Work Environment Claim
About this document
- Layer
- attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
- Type as titled
- ia investigation report (kind from doc_type)
- File
- f21cb069e285f4ad7423c3dba85bc71b160d60ac application/pdf
- Cases
About: James Mutuku (case)
Smith has not observed any hostile or retaliatory behavior by a supervisor toward Complainant He has not observed any inflammatory behavior by Complainant toward supervision, but said Complainant was "argumentative" with supervision. He has heard rumors of confrontations but has never witnessed this.
Smith recalled being moved around (from beat to beat) as an officer, even a senior officer. He thought staffing levels were probably at their worst in 2017 and were headed in that direction today with officers being on light duty, away at training, promotions, etc. Backfills are used to meet minimum staffing levels for each watch. Supervisors are constantly shuffling officers to determine what beats they will work. The officers' pay and duties are the same, they just may be working in a different beat. Smith sometimes moves a senior officer so he can keep his officers together to train and mentor them. He doesn't move them to upset them, and it is not personal. He said there were also officers that like being moved and he found this productive. Senior officers were shown as much respect as possible, but they still might be asked to hold over or change beats. It's not personal. It's just moving officers to make the shift work. Smith added, "The mission comes first."
Smith did not know if Complainant and Weddle ever put themselves "10-6" (busy), but said he knew them and knew they took lunch and snack breaks. It was absolutely ok to take a lunch break.
Nobody from command approached Smith and told him he needed to let Officer 1 and Officer 2 ride together because they feared if they didn't allow this, the Department would get sued. Smith said it was his decision to allow them to ride together and he would be blindsided if anything negative ever came from Officer 1 or Officer 2. There was never any mention about either of them being a protected class. Smith had an agreement with them at shift change and they stuck with the agreement. There was no issue, except for Complainant complaint.
In closing, Smith said has not heard from Complainant since Smith moved to graveyard. Complainant has not sent him a text and they don't see each other in the gym anymore. Complainant was the only one that expressed any issue with Officer 1 and Officer 2 riding together. Smith even asked Maggie Kouroubacalis, while he was still on swings, if any of the other officers expressed concerns. She assured him nobody else had an issue with the arrangement. All the sergeants on swing shift and Officer 4 supported Officer 1 and Officer 2 riding together. Smith didn't think Complainant had an issue anymore either since he hadn't heard from him since moving to graveyard. Smith was surprised when he learned he would be called as a witness in this investigation.
Medici asked Smith if he would split a two-person ride if they were not productive. Smith answered, "Immediately." Smith said he would separate a two-person ride if they were not productive or if one officer was not a good influence on the other. He has done it before and would do it again. This is common sense and taking care of your officers, this is not indicative of a hostile work environment. It is not a right to ride as a two-person ride and supervisors switched officers around constantly. In Smith's opinion, a two-person ride should be the hardest working unit in the beat. Based on his observations, Officer 1 and Officer 2 were running circles around the other officers. They were on the radio the entire shift, they were
Administrative Investigation: PC2211047 / Hostile Work Environment Claim
Page 66 of 155
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.