Documents › f21cb069e285f4ad7423c3dba85bc71b160d60ac:1-155

Riverside Police Department Administrative Investigation PA2211047 / Hostile Work Environment Claim

POST board investigation reportagency investigation 2022-04-10 155 pages (file pages 1–155) original file
About this document
Layer
attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
Type as titled
ia investigation report (kind from doc_type)
File
f21cb069e285f4ad7423c3dba85bc71b160d60ac application/pdf
Cases
POST 2303451 · James Mutuku (filed under case)

About: James Mutuku (case)

Page 62 · file page 62 larger image
Image of page 62; its text is alongside
Text: OCR

Smith said, "I think Lieutenant Officer 4 sees everything in whole, takes everything into account, uh... believes in troop welfare. Um... tries to make accommodations when he can." Smith said Officer 4 was always very accommodating when people wanted to ride together in certain areas. He said, "Swing shift is a mess. The roster is a mess. I feel bad for anybody that goes up there and tries to put that thing together." But Officer 4 knows exactly what is going on in the city, knows exactly what is going on with all the officers and sergeants assigned to him, is well aware of everything going on, and is in control. Smith said Officer 4 was probably the best watch commander we had.

I asked if he thought Officer 4 moved Complainant to Area 5 to retaliate against him for reporting an issue to Internal Affairs about Officer 1 and Officer 2 not taking a report, or if Officer 4 did this simply because he was trying to put the roster together. Smith said he did not believe for any reason Officer 4 did this as a form of retaliation. Officer 4 was one of the smartest people Smith knew, extremely professional, and Smith didn't think he would ever do anything to compromise this shift or any of the officers. Smith did not think he would do anything out of spite or revenge, or to prove something. Smith has observed Complainant and Officer 4 speak on numerous occasions. He described these as normal conversations and said Officer 4 was always very approachable, easy to talk to, didn't get too caught up in the rank, and you could have a normal conversation with him as an officer. Smith said they moved people around constantly and he thought maybe it was just Complainant turn to get moved. He again mentioned Sears and Kouroubacalis regularly getting moved and both were senior officers. Smith said, "And Compl would come up to the bench, every single time, almost every single day, and ask about the roster." He would question why Sears was going to the eastside and why the "two girls" (Officer 1 and Officer 2) were working "there when they could work west." He said, "Everyday it's like we almost had to approve the roster through him." Smith wasn't there, but thought Complainant was moved probably because they needed someone east to go west. He said Officer 4 probably looked around the room, saw he had previously asked other officers to move, so he chose Complainant because it was his turn. Smith said that's how he would've done it if he were the watch commander. This was similar to how we assigned holdovers. In the past when we needed holdovers, we always used to only use the junior officers, but now we use the officers on their Mondays. Smith now has senior officers that have to holdover.

Complainant came up to Smith and Officer 3 who were seated at the front of roll call to ask about Sears being moved. This conversation occurred on or about the second time they moved Sears and Complainant advised them Sears had an issue with being moved. Smith tried to explain to Complainant that Sears was not assigned to that beat, Sears just preferred to work there. Sears was assigned east with Officer 3 and he needed to work there, so Smith could keep his crew together under his supervision. Smith had six officers assigned to him and he was trying to keep at least four of them in the same beat under his supervision. Though Sears did not come to Smith with the issue, Smith talked to Sears about a week later. He told Sears he would try to keep him north as much as he could, and Sears appreciated it. It was Complainant though that told Smith he was wrong for moving Sears and that designators were everything to senior officers. Smith told him he was once a senior officer and understood, but moves were going to be made.

Two to three days per week, sergeants had to talk to Complainant about the roster, who should ride as partners, and where officers should be assigned to work. Smith said this occurred at least

Administrative Investigation: PC2211047 / Hostile Work Environment Claim
Page 62 of 155

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.