Riverside Police Department Administrative Investigation PA2211047 / Hostile Work Environment Claim
About this document
- Layer
- attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
- Type as titled
- ia investigation report (kind from doc_type)
- File
- f21cb069e285f4ad7423c3dba85bc71b160d60ac application/pdf
- Cases
About: James Mutuku (case)
explained a two-person ride still allowed for one officer and their car to be available. He gave an example of a two-person ride booking someone into custody and/or doing the paperwork. The other officer would still technically be available. Also, Smith has supervised Officer 1 and Officer 2 in the past. He knows how much they appreciate working together. He described them as "a super productive two-officer ride." To him, a thirty-minute lactation break in the middle of the shift and never taking a lunch break which they are authorized to do, was no different than an officer going to In-N-Out or El Pollo Loco for thirty-minutes to an hour. He said Officer 1 and Officer 2 never put themselves on lunch or showed themselves as busy at any station to take a lunch break. Smith did not see the problem with Officer 1 and Officer 2 taking this break, so Officer 1 could take care of her family. In addition, he could always help if needed as he was an additional car. He could back Officer 2 and he also went to calls. Officer 1 and Officer 2 always let him know when they would go 10-6 and it was always when there was a lull in the shift. It was never when things were "jumping off." He never once questioned when they took the break; calls were never stacked on the board and there was never a hot call.
I told Smith we heard from two officers that in the months that followed shift change, Officer 1 and Officer 2 breaks became longer. Smith did not notice but said every two days Officer 1 and Officer 2 would remind him that he did not approve of Officer 1 and Officer 2 riding together and kept track of them. A couple times Officer 1 and Officer 2 had come to Smith and told him Officer 1 and Officer 2 had taken thirty-five minutes; one time it was forty minutes. To Smith, anything under an hour was reasonable. It was the same as taking a lunch break and she was taking care of her family. He said, there was never a critical incident that made him ask where Officer 2 or Officer 1 were. For the two months Officer 1 and Officer 2 worked for him, their breaks were always reasonable. If the lactation break took twenty-five minutes and they wanted to spend another ten minutes at the station to warm their food and eat, he was good with it. It was Smith's opinion that mattered. He was their supervisor. He knew if anything happened, Officer 2 would leave Officer 1 at the station to go and handle. He also knew Officer 2 was taking phone reports during Officer 1 lactation breaks.
I asked Smith to describe the conversation he had with Officer 1 and Officer 2 riding. Officer 1 and Smith had a couple conversations, but the first one was the "bigger one." Officer 1 and Smith have known each other a long time and Smith believed Officer 1 had some level of respect for him; Smith said Officer 1 didn't show a lot of respect for most supervisors. Smith tried to explain to Officer 1 policy, law, his belief in troop welfare, and his belief that a two-officer ride was greater for the Department versus splitting them up. Smith believed it was more productive for the Department to keep them together. Smith said, "So the conversation starts with he Officer 1 did not believe they should ride together, but I felt it was personal." Smith did not know if it was because Officer 1 was a senior officer and felt Officer 1 and Officer 2 weren't doing enough. He did not know what Officer 1 issue was, but felt it was personal. He has known Officer 1 a long time and never really thought, "Oh, that's what I should do." when Officer 1 gave his opinions. The conversation was really Officer 1 voicing his opinion that they shouldn't ride together, it wasn't fair, and they were taking a car out of service. After Smith explained policy, law, and his opinion on the matter, in "normal fashion" they were good for about a week or so. Then something must have happened, like Officer 1 had to take a report, because Officer 1 and Officer 2 were on a lactation break. Officer 1 brought it to Smith's attention again.
Administrative Investigation: PC2211047 / Hostile Work Environment Claim
Page 59 of 155
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.