Documents › f21cb069e285f4ad7423c3dba85bc71b160d60ac:1-155

Riverside Police Department Administrative Investigation PA2211047 / Hostile Work Environment Claim

POST board investigation reportagency investigation 2022-04-10 155 pages (file pages 1–155) original file
About this document
Layer
attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
Type as titled
ia investigation report (kind from doc_type)
File
f21cb069e285f4ad7423c3dba85bc71b160d60ac application/pdf
Cases
POST 2303451 · James Mutuku (filed under case)

About: James Mutuku (case)

Page 107 · file page 107 larger image
Image of page 107; its text is alongside
Text: OCR

J. Mutuku advised issues between Complainant and his wife, Officer Officer 1 started about two and half years ago. When Officer 1 first started here, she worked the eastside with Officer Officer 2 and Complainant and Officer 1 talked a lot as he tried to mentor her and the relationship between the three officers was good. J. Mutuku warned Officer 1 to be careful around Complainant because he had seen this play out before. He was specifically referring to Complainant and Melissa Cunningham (former officer). This was also a situation where Complainant tried to mentor a young female officer. It was known Complainant and Cunningham were very close initially and they rode as partners. The two had a difference of opinion about something, but Cunningham held her ground. This soured the relationship between them, and it got ugly. Complainant would publicly bash Cunningham all the time and talk about her fertility issues. J. Mutuku told Officer 1 and Officer 2 to be friendly toward Complainant but to be careful. He said they shouldn't think for one second that just because they were females, Complainant wouldn't become malicious with them like he would with a male.

The relationship changed when Officer 1 and Officer 2 failed to respond to a call fast enough for Complainant who had requested a camera. When they arrived, Complainant "barked" at them and they "barked back." J. Mutuku believed the relationship soured from that point. J. Mutuku told Officer 1 and Officer 2 to stay away from Complainant and not try to mend the relationship. He told them Complainant would never get over "two twenty-year-old girls fronting him off."

After that incident, Complainant began to call them out over the radio and was very rude and brash toward them. Officer 1 and Officer 2 thought Complainant was trying to bully them out of the eastside, but they continued to work there anyway.

When J. Mutuku first started, he heard about "the legend of" Complainant in a positive way, but never witnessed it. Though Complainant was disgruntled, J. Mutuku gave him a little respect based on what older officers said about him. J. Mutuku noticed immediately however, Complainant would bash J. Mutuku's supervisor, Sergeant Kendal Banks. Complainant would constantly ask J. Mutuku what Banks said to him or advised him to do and then tell J. Mutuku that Banks was wrong or oppose what Banks had advised. J. Mutuku tried to distance himself from Complainant but not disrespectfully. He was new and didn't want to be around Complainant negativity. There was never a confrontation between them, but J. Mutuku would steer clear of places where Complainant was. J. Mutuku described Complainant as disgruntled and very negative.

I asked J. Mutuku to describe Complainant today, over thirteen years later, leaving out the issues with Officer 1 and Officer 2. J. Mutuku answered, "He's toxic." As a supervisor, J. Mutuku has a good relationship with the officers, especially those with less than five years of service. He said the general consensus is that most of the officers do not respect Complainant think he is toxic, and he is in this category with only two or three other officers in the Department. Officers try to stay far away from Complainant and know that if they need an emergency back, Complainant won't come. Complainant is a toxic employee to young officers, but fortunately the young officers today recognize he is toxic faster than the officers of J. Mutuku's generation. There aren't many officers sharing the legend of Complainant anymore; that generation has died out. J. Mutuku said one hundred percent, if a blind survey of patrol officers was taken, officers would rank Complainant as a toxic employee.

Administrative Investigation: PC2211047 / Hostile Work Environment Claim
Page 107 of 155

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.