Robert Handy Expert Report regarding LAPD Shooting involving Officers Zavala and Quintanilla
About this document
- Layer
- attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
- Type as titled
- sme report (kind from doc_type)
- File
- f0e56d92560ff7aa0d5c7a58497aad2f16fccab6 application/pdf
- Cases
About: Jose Zavala (case), Julio Quintanilla (case)
Expert Report: Robert Handy
LAPD OIS on 12-18-2021
Involving Officers Zavala and Quintanilla
Basis for Opinion
Police officers are taught the legal authority and considerations for using deadly force. The legal authority and standards for lethal force are based on an objective reasonableness standard based on the Constitution's Fourth Amendment, as determined by the U.S. Supreme Court. Officers are taught that they may use deadly force when it reasonably appears necessary to stop an imminent threat of death or serious bodily injury based on the totality of the circumstances presented to them at the time. The force they use must be objectively reasonable compared to the threat, resistance, and other circumstances perceived by or known to the officer when the force was used9.
The California Penal Code further instructs officers on the definition of an imminent threat, which is required for a peace officer to use deadly force in California.
"A threat of death or serious bodily injury is 'imminent' when, based on the totality of the circumstances, a reasonable officer in the same situation would believe that a person has the present ability, opportunity, and apparent intent to immediately cause death or serious bodily injury to the peace officer or another person. An imminent harm is not merely a fear of future harm, no matter how great the fear and no matter how great the likelihood of the harm, but is one that, from appearances, must be instantly confronted and addressed10."
In this instance, Sergeant, and Officers Zavala, Quintanilla, O-1, O-2, Meraz, Officer 4, and Officer 3 were in the immediate area and involved in the contact with Victim. Initial contact with Victim was made when Sergeant arrived, followed shortly by Officers Zavala and Quintanilla. The other officers arrived shortly thereafter as the incident continued.
Sergeant supervised the scene and issued orders assigning specific tasks to the officers. Sergeant's initial organization of the officers and division of specific responsibilities was consistent with contemporary training and standards for handling such incidents.
Officers Zavala and Quintanilla were assigned as lethal coverage officers by Sergeant, meaning they were to have their firearms out and pointed at the suspect in case an imminent deadly threat was presented. Officer 1 and Officer 4 maintained positions with less lethal tools, Officer 1 with a 40mm and Officer 4 with a beanbag shotgun. Officer Meraz was assigned as lethal coverage and positioned himself next to Officer 111.
At approximately 1704 hours, Sergeant decided to have Officer 1 fire the 40 mm projectile as described in the previous section. The first attempted use of the 40 mm struck Victim in the abdomen but had little effect; it did appear to get Victim to sit down again, this time on the bottom step of the apartment building12.
9 CA POST Learning Domain 20, Chapter 3, 4
10 CA Penal Code 835(a)(e)(2)
11 FID Report
12 Quintanilla BWC 3:35-3:42
5
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.