Robert Handy Expert Report regarding LAPD Shooting involving Officers Zavala and Quintanilla
About this document
- Layer
- attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
- Type as titled
- sme report (kind from doc_type)
- File
- f0e56d92560ff7aa0d5c7a58497aad2f16fccab6 application/pdf
- Cases
About: Jose Zavala (case), Julio Quintanilla (case)
Expert Report: Robert Handy
LAPD OIS on 12-18-2021
Involving Officers Zavala and Quintanilla
detention must be based on reasonable suspicion that unlawful activity has occurred, is taking place, or is about to occur, and that the person detained is connected to that activity3.
In this instance, the officers were responding to radio calls of a subject threatening suicide with a knife. They also received information that Victim was chasing people down the street with a knife. Sergeant was first to arrive, followed by Officers Zavala and Quintanilla. When Sergeant arrived, he observed Victim sitting on the exterior stairs of the apartment building holding a knife in his right hand. Victim was holding the blade of the knife pressed up against his neck.
At this point, the officers had information that Victim was suicidal and that he had chased people down the street with the knife. When they arrived, they confirmed that Victim was armed with a large, meat cleaver-style knife. The response from Sergeant, Officer Zavala, and Officer Quintanilla when they arrived and exited their cars was to draw their weapons and give Victim orders to drop the knife. The officers had parked their police vehicles perpendicular to the apartment building and were using their vehicle doors as partial cover and concealment while giving commands to Victim4. The presence of the marked vehicles, officers in uniform, and the orders given to Victim constituted an attempt to detain Victim and prevent harm to himself or others and further investigate the reports of assaults with the knife before the officers' arrival. Based on the totality of the circumstances, the attempt to detain Victim using officer presence, verbal commands, and the display of firearms was appropriate and consistent with police officer training, standards, and practices in California and across the United States.
- 3. The use of 40 mm less lethal munitions to get Victim to drop the knife and comply with orders from the officers was appropriate and consistent with training, practices, and the standards for police officers in California and across the country.
Basis for Opinion
Sergeant, along with Officers Zavala and Quintanilla, were engaging with Victim when additional officers arrived. As officers arrived, Sergeant assigned them to positions (specific angles of coverage) and to specific responsibilities, such as serving as less-lethal or cover officers. Officer 1 ended up with a less lethal assignment, positioning himself with a 40 mm less lethal launcher pointed at Victim. Sergeant assigned officers Zavala and Quintanilla lethal coverage. Officers Officer 2 and Officer 3 were assigned as an arrest team. The air unit arrived, and the pilot and tactical flight officer directed responding units to perimeter and crowd control positions.
3 CA POST Learning Domain 15, Chapter 3
4 FID Report, BWC, Zavala, Quintanilla, Sergeant
3
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.