Documents › ee9d702905639628c9a7271797da1d967fd66f44:52-78

Board of Civil Service Commissioners Hearing Report - Macario Sanchez (File No. 55836)

Agency records investigation reportagency investigation 2024-10-02 Los Angeles Port Police Department 27 pages (file pages 52–78) original file
About this document
Layer
agency record: part of a file an agency produced
Type as titled
civil service commission hearing report (kind from doc_type)
Produced as
los-angeles-port-police/IA20-009 Redacted for public release per 832.7.pdf
File
ee9d702905639628c9a7271797da1d967fd66f44 application/pdf
Cases
agency:C-529c48bac5 · Macario Sanchez (record)
agency:C-b1a07fa34a · Macario Sanchez (record)

About: Macario Sanchez (case), Macario Sanchez (case)

Page 21 · file page 72 larger image
Image of page 21; its text is alongside
Text: OCR

For the most part, there were satisfactory explanations for what she said. The victim said she let him into the home rather than have the Appellant wake up the entire household, including her parents. In addition, the Department noted victims of sexual assault are often unable to accurately recall certain events. With the Appellant claiming he was unable to confirm or deny what occurred, the Department was right to conclude he was sexually assaulted his [REDACTED] even though there were some factual discrepancies her statements. Her claims as to what occurred were both supported by the medical examination conducted by the Sexual Abuse Response Team (SART) after the assault and the electronic statements between the victim and the Appellant.

In support of his assertion Policy Section 2.130 was not violated, he noted that on January 12, 2021 the case was referred to the District Attorney and that after reviewing the material, decided not to file criminal charges. This decision against moving forwards with a prosecution was harmful to the Department's case. In addition to the higher standard of proof required in a criminal case, the D.A.'s decision was at least in part, due to the victim's preference not to pursue the matter.

The Appellant also argued the investigation was biased in that the Department made up its mind before hand and was not really interested in looking for what really happened (Ex 2 p. 4). As an example, he pointed to the investigators trying to talk to the victim again even though they knew she did not want to pursue the matter any further. The Department's response was they did to meet with her again to clarify a few things, but primarily to be sympathetic and put her at ease while she was in such an emotional state (Ex 2 p. 3). This was a reasonable explanation and was not indicative of his employer trying to bolster a decision to discipline the Appellant. The Appellant did not point to any witness or document evidencing bias or give an

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.