Investigative Summary and Findings: Michael Kim (POST2410050)
About this document
- Layer
- attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
- Type as titled
- investigative summary and findings (kind from doc_type)
- File
- ebe28d3a17018e49ac8e17b6c274d37da3a704ab application/pdf
- Cases
About: Michael Kim (case)
- ○ Respondent knowingly and willfully lied to a federal court when he signed this Declaration.
- ○ Respondent obstructed justice in a federal criminal case by signing a Declaration that he knew contained false information.
- ● Respondent was dishonest in a criminal investigation of Andy Li when he made statements to FBI Special Agents on August 19, 2014, during an interview about Andy Li and his Declaration that were materially false, including that:
- ○ He did not know that Andy Li had a ballistic vest;
- ○ He dropped off a work-issued ballistic vest with his wife, who was at Li's wife's (Mimi Li) beauty salon, while he went out drinking with friends; and
- ○ He tried to get the vest back but forgot about the vest over time.
- ● Respondent stated that he made materially false statements in a memorandum he submitted to then-Chief Deputy Matthew Freeman, SF SO, which repeated the lies he told FBI Special Agents.56
The admissions in Respondent's Plea Agreement stand as evidence beyond a reasonable doubt that he lied to the Court in the Li prosecution and that he lied to FBI Special Agents in connection with their investigation of criminal activity and his own peace officer misconduct. The beyond a reasonable doubt evidentiary standard is far higher than the clear and convincing evidentiary standard required in this investigation.
In support of his guilty plea, Respondent stated to the Court that he knowingly and willfully lied to the Court:
On August 6, 2014, I signed a Declaration. I knew and intended that the Declaration would be provided to the Court for the purpose of Andy Li's attorneys to seek the release of Andy Li. In connection with that Declaration, I falsely declared that my wife had taken a ballistic vest with her to see the wife of Andy Li. I falsely declared that my wife had forgotten the vest at the workplace of the wife of Andy Li. I falsely declared that the wife of Andy Li had placed the vest in the trunk of her car. I falsely declared that I had not retrieved the vest from the wife of Andy Li. In truth and in fact, I had loaned my ballistic vest — issued to me by the San Francisco Sheriff's Department — to Andy Li for his
56 Although Respondent stated to the FBI that he submitted a memorandum containing lies to his chain of command and admitted the same in his background investigation file, I was unable to locate a copy of the memorandum. Attachment P at 012 (Background Investigation File at 360 ("35") I falsified a memo I wrote to my supervisor. This was related to the misdemeanor contempt of court charge."); Attachment P at 007 (Background Investigation File at 74 (Personal History Statement – Peace Officer (POST 2-251))(8/1/2021)("I wrote a memo to Chief Deputy Matthew Freeman stating the same fact. The FBI arrived at my work and interviewed me about my statement that was filed in court. I told the FBI the same story.")); Attachment S (FBI Interview of Michael Kim, FD-302 at 2 (8/19/2024) ("KIM stated he let his SF SO Chief know about the circumstances involving the ballistic vest approximately two weeks ago.")). In my investigation I contacted Mr. Freeman by phone and U.S. mail to interview him about the memorandum from Respondent. Mr. Freeman did not respond to my requests to be interviewed.
Investigative Summary and Findings
Michael Kim (Respondent)
Case Number POST2410050
Page 19 of 27
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.