Documents › e628c297484336068eee0f6d3ca7839d2ba7b3d2:9-28
758 - BR01_POST2311370_Zavala_Jose_ISF_Redacted.pdf
About this document
- Layer
- packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
- Type as titled
- isf (kind from doc_type)
- File
- e628c297484336068eee0f6d3ca7839d2ba7b3d2 application/pdf
- Cases
About: Jose Zavala (case)
Page 17 · file page 25
larger image
Text: digital text layer
Investigative Summary and Recommendation
Jose ZAVALA (Respondent)
Case Number POST2311370
Page 17
that Respondent failed to leverage reasonable and available less-lethal alternatives at
the time deadly force was utilized. Accordingly, Respondent’s use of deadly force was
both unreasonable and excessive.
Under California Penal Code section 835a(a)(2), “peace officers use deadly force only
when necessary, in defense of human life. In determining whether deadly force is
necessary, officers shall evaluate each situation in light of the particular circumstances
of each case and shall use other available resources and techniques if reasonably safe
and feasible to an objectively reasonable officer.” Here, Respondent requested an
ambulance upon arrival at the incident but did not request support from LAPD’s Mental
Evaluation Unit (MEU), despite having completed “Mental Health Intervention” training
10 months prior. Prior to Respondent’s use of deadly force, officers fired two rounds
from a LLL device, hardly exhausting its potential benefit, and the on scene commander
(OSC) had not readied or directed the deployment of other available less-lethal options
such as the “Bean Bag” shotgun, Conducted Energy Devices (CED) “taser,” or a
ballistic shield team equipped with CEDs and/or Oleoresin Capsicum (OC) “pepper”
spray. Respondent’s use of force did not result from an order from the OSC to employ
lethal force. More importantly, the absence of the OSC’s order to deploy other less-
lethal options does not necessarily mean that the OSC wasn’t considering them, nor did
it render the threat posed by the Victim more imminent.
During his LAPD Complaint interview,25 Respondent stated he was afraid Victim was
going to come at him with the butcher knife and harm him or his partner. To protect
himself, his partner and nearby citizens from imminent serious bodily injury, Respondent
said he fired “two to three rounds” to stop the threat. LAPD’s Personnel Complaint
Investigation SUSTAINED that Respondent’s use of lethal force was unreasonable. The
subsequent Complaint Investigation initiated by the Victim’s family, alleging
Respondent’s use of excessive force, reached a contradictory finding of UNFOUNDED;
however, this investigation also appeared to focus on the moment Respondent used
deadly force and did not consider the following relevant circumstances:
• Victim was contained - never closer than approximately 22 feet to any officer;
• Officers were positioned behind the cover of police vehicles;
• Victim only appeared to pose a danger to himself;26
• Once contained, Victim did not exhibit a demeanor that was particularly
threatening, nor did he exhibit an intent to injure officers/others;
• State of Victim’s mental/physical health, cognitive function and/or influence from
alcohol or controlled substances;
25 Attachment I (Respondent’s Interview Transcript).
26 California Penal Code section 835a(c)(2) states that “a peace officer shall not use deadly force against a person
based on the danger that person poses to themselves, if an objectively reasonable officer would believe the person
does not pose an imminent threat of death or serious bodily injury to the peace officer or to another person.”
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.