Documents › e628c297484336068eee0f6d3ca7839d2ba7b3d2:9-28
758 - BR01_POST2311370_Zavala_Jose_ISF_Redacted.pdf
About this document
- Layer
- packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
- Type as titled
- isf (kind from doc_type)
- File
- e628c297484336068eee0f6d3ca7839d2ba7b3d2 application/pdf
- Cases
About: Jose Zavala (case)
Page 16 · file page 24
larger image
Text: digital text layer
Investigative Summary and Recommendation
Jose ZAVALA (Respondent)
Case Number POST2311370
Page 16
‘objectively reasonable.’”17 The Court also reaffirmed that an “inquiry into
reasonableness…requires assessing the ‘totality of the circumstances.’”18
In issuing its ruling, the Court rejected the “so-called moment-of-threat rule” adopted by
lower courts, which “looks only to the circumstances existing at the precise time an
officer perceived the threat inducing him to shoot.”19 Rather, the Court reiterated that
“all the relevant circumstances, including facts and events leading up to the climactic
moment…” must be considered when determining “whether a peace officer acted
reasonably in using force.”20
The Felix opinion is consistent with California law. Under Penal Code section 835a,
peace officers may use deadly force “only when necessary in defense of human life.”21
Further, although peace officers may use “objectively reasonable force to effect
arrest…,” prevent escape, or overcome resistance, deadly force is only justified “when
the officer reasonably believes, based on the totality of the circumstances, that such
force is necessary…” to: 1) “defend against an imminent threat of death or serious
bodily injury to the officer or another person…;” or 2) “apprehend a fleeing person for
any felony that threatened or resulted in death or serious bodily injury, if the officer
reasonably believes that the person will cause death or serious bodily injury to another
unless immediately apprehended.”22 However, a “peace officer shall not use deadly
force against a person based on the danger that person poses to themselves, if an
objectively reasonable officer would believe the person does not pose an imminent
threat of death or serious bodily injury to the peace officer or to another person.”23
In reviewing Respondent’s statements regarding his decision to use deadly force, his
decision was based primarily on the moments immediately preceding the application of
deadly force without appearing to consider all relevant circumstances leading up to that
moment. When applying the “totality of the circumstances” as required under Felix,
Graham v. Connor, and Penal Code section 835a, however,24 the Division concluded
17 Barnes v. Felix (2025) 605 U.S. 73, 76 (“Felix”), citing Graham v. Connor (1989) 490 U.S. 386, 397 (“Graham v.
Connor”) [internal citations omitted].
18 Id., citing Graham at 396.
19 Id.
20 Id.
21 Pen. Code § 835a, subd. (a)(1).
22 Pen. Code § 835a, subd. (c)(1)(A)-(B).
23 Pen. Code § 835a, subd. (c)(2).
24 Under Penal Code section 835a(a)(2), “in determining whether deadly force is necessary, officers shall evaluate
each situation in light of the particular circumstances of each case and shall use other available resources and
techniques if reasonably safe and feasible to an objectively reasonable officer.”
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.