Folsom PD Internal Affairs Investigation IA 24-004
About this document
- Layer
- agency record: part of a file an agency produced
- Type as titled
- ia investigation report (kind from doc_type)
- Produced as
- folsom-police-department/IA 24-004 Final Release.pdf
- File
- c93848aa2bbdb41ec3ce59408815573609c88ef7 application/pdf
- Cases
About: David Erler (case)
Memo
was taken back because when he ended the conversation there were no signs of remorse or any form of apology from Detective Erler regarding the misleading statements.
I asked Fire Investigator Sargent if he could explain the time gap between when [REDACTED] saw the fire in the backyard around 2100 hours on 07/23/2024 to when the structure fire was called in on 07/24/2024 around 0308 hours. Fire Investigator Sargent stated it could have possibly been a hot ember that caught the house on fire or if the tree root system was still on fire underground and the roots reached over to the resident of [REDACTED].
I asked Fire Investigator Sargent about Detective Erler's statement that he lit the tree stump on fire using only a barbecue lighter and if that was possible. Fire Investigator Sargent stated it was very unlikely and there would most likely been an accelerant used. Fire Investigator Sargent stated Detective Erler mentioned that he drilled holes into the stump and then lit it on fire. Fire Investigator Sargent stated one method is to drill holes into the stump which are then filled with an accelerant. Fire Investigator Sargent stated Detective Erler had two barbecues in his backyard which were not affected by the fire. One was a smoker style and the other was a charcoal style barbecue. There was lighter fluid next to the barbecue. Fire Investigator Sargent stated he was not able to test for any type of accelerant due to the active fire suppression occurring during the time of his investigation.
I asked Fire Investigator Sargent if he inspected the HVAC system to determine if it was the cause of the fire due to Detective Erler's comment about it and Fire Investigator Sargent stated he did. Fire Investigator Sargent stated the HVAC system was not the cause of the fire and that all the evidence showed the cause of the fire was the palm tree stump in Detective Erler's backyard which was next to the fence that separated the two houses affected by the fire.
Fire Investigator Sargent informed me that he was taken back by his contact with Detective Erler due to several issues. Fire Investigator Sargent stated he was a Sheriff Deputy with the El Dorado County Sheriff's Office for 21 years prior to becoming a Fire Investigator. Fire Investigator Sargent stated after he had talked to [REDACTED] and his wife [REDACTED] he walked over to where Detective Erler and his wife [REDACTED] Erler were at which was a neighbor's house. As Fire Investigator Sargent was walking towards Detective Erler and his wife, Detective Erler looked at Fire Investigator Sargent and then turned around and said something to his wife [REDACTED] Erler before turning back around to face Fire Investigator Sargent. This reminded Fire Investigator Sargent of
Page 6 of 47
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.