Cases › agency:C-12b9c9bd93

24-002 | 24-004 | 22-1093 | IA 24-004

Agency records · officer x incident · David Erler · Folsom Police Department
Case id
C-12b9c9bd93
Agency case no.
24-002 | 24-004 | 22-1093 | IA 24-004
Incident dates
2022-04-28 (1 incident)
Category
—
Agency finding
sustained
Discipline
termination of employment | probation period was extended for three months | Termination from Employment | request to extend his probationary period for up to 90 days and withhold his merit increase | Modified work duty status; assigned to the records unit; not to function as a police officer or display a badge or weapon | probation is being extended by 90 days | Termination | probation period was extended for three months, from August 1, 2022, to November 1, 2022 | paid Administrative Leave

Summary direct quote

Failure to participate in, or giving false or misleading statements, or misrepresenting or omitting material information to a supervisor or other person of authority, in connection with any investigation; Criminal, dishonest, or disgraceful conduct; and other conduct unbecoming a member of this department. Specifically, Erler is alleged to have lied to a fire investigator about burning a stump and using an accelerant the night before a structure fire, and suggesting a neighbor's HVAC system was the cause. | Detective David Erler was involved in off-duty conduct which may be considered unbecoming of a member of this department or tends to reflect unfavorably upon this department or its members. Gave false or misleading statements or admitted material information to a person of authority in connection with an investigation. And committed conduct that was dishonest or disgraceful off duty that adversely effects the member's relationship with this department. | involved in off-duty conduct which may be considered unbecoming by a member of this department, or tends to reflect unfavorably upon this department or its members, gave false or misleading statements, or omitted material information to a person of authority in connection with an investigation, and committed conduct that was dishonest, or disgraceful off duty that adversely affects the member's relationship with this department. | Failure to participate in, or giving false or misleading statements, or misrepresenting or omitting material information to a supervisor or other person of authority; criminal, dishonest, or disgraceful conduct; and conduct unbecoming a member of the department, specifically regarding lying to a fire investigator and insurance adjuster about burning a stump that caused a structure fire. | Giving false or misleading statements, or misrepresenting or omitting material information to a supervisor or other person of authority, in connection with any investigation or in reporting or any department related business and dishonest or disgraceful conduct, whether on or off duty, that adversely affects the member's relationship with this department | you (Officer Erler at the time) took no notes while conducting a DUI investigation and then did not review your body worn camera footage to assist with preparation of the associated arrest report. Discrepancies were found between the official arrest report and what was captured on your body worn camera | Det. Erler is alleged to have denied his involvement with a fire, spread rumors about a neighbor's HVAC system as the cause, and been untruthful with Fire Investigator Sargent and Grange Insurance regarding the cause of the fire, specifically lying about burning a stump the night before. | Failed to make mention of his BWC being present or activated (it wasn't activated) and failed to complete a felony investigation for an explosive used to destroy a mailbox, instead telling suspects to return and repair it without asking the victim if they'd like to pursue prosecution. | Detective Erler provided misleading statements and omitted material information to a fire investigator and insurance adjuster regarding burning a stump and using an accelerant during a structure fire investigation, while suggesting a neighbor's HVAC system may have caused the fire. | took no notes while conducting a DUI investigation and then did not review your body worn camera footage to assist with preparation of the associated arrest report. Discrepancies were found between the official arrest report and what was captured on your body worn camera | Mr. Erler provided misleading information throughout when he indicated that the fire could have started from his neighbor's new AC unit and not being entirely truthful about burning a tree stump in his backyard, and indicated that he did lie to the Fire Investigator. | Poor report preparation (lacking detail and thoroughness), no reference to BWC being present or activated, no reference to attempting to obtain security footage or interview witnesses, and providing contradictory statements regarding receipt of emails from a victim. | you informed [Sergeant Mendenhall] that you had not received any email from the victim... Lieutenant Wright followed up with the victim asking for an email correspondence showing he had emailed you, which he did and was contrary to what you told Sergeant Mendenhall. | Detective Erler provided false and misleading statements to a fire investigator and insurance adjuster regarding a structure fire, denying he burned a palm tree stump and falsely suggesting a neighbor's HVAC system was the cause; he also denied using an accelerant. | The officer is alleged to have been burning a stump in his backyard the night before a fire occurred and subsequently failed to be honest and forthcoming about the cause of the fire, potentially telling coworkers it was caused by a neighbor's air conditioner. | Detective Erler provided false or misleading statements and omitted material information to a fire investigator, his supervisor, and an insurance adjuster regarding the burning of a palm tree stump and the use of an accelerant prior to a structure fire. | Officer Erler took no notes while conducting a DUI investigation and then did not review his body worn camera footage to assist with preparation of the associated arrest report, resulting in discrepancies between the report and the footage. | Detective Erler is alleged to have been untruthful to a Fire Investigator about burning a stump the night prior to a structure fire and continued to mislead others about the neighbor's HVAC system being the cause of the fire. | you informed [Sergeant Mendenhall] that you had not received any email from the victim... The victim sent Lieutenant Wright a copy of the email(s) in question, demonstrating that what you told Sergeant Mendenhall was false. | you informed [Sergeant Mendenhall] that you had not received any email from the victim. The victim sent Lieutenant Wright a copy of the email(s) in question, demonstrating that what you told Sergeant Mendenhall was false. | During a DUI investigation, failed to take notes, produced a report with several discrepancies compared to BWC footage, and failed to review his own BWC footage to aid in the writing and accuracy of his report. | Officer Erler falsely informed Sergeant Mendenhall that he had not received an email from a victim in an assault case, which was later proven false by the victim providing the emails to Lieutenant Wright. | Officer was burning a stump in his backyard at 9 o'clock at night; the fire was 'pretty big' and 'up over the fence', and the witness's house caught fire at 3 o'clock in the morning. | Mr Erler had lied numerous times about what may have been the cause [of a fire] and even stated it may have come from our home... he would lie multiple times to a fire investigator. | Officer Erler is alleged to have been untruthful during a fire investigation, initially denying he was burning a stump and suggesting a neighbor's HVAC system caused the fire. | concerns about the investigation and Detective Erler's involvement regarding a structure fire which occurred at Detective David Erler's residence and his neighbor's residence | Investigation regarding a structure fire at his residence and whether he was dishonest about the cause, specifically regarding lighting a stump on fire. | The ignition source of the fire was from intentional application of open flame for the purposes of stump removal, which extended to two structures. | Ofc. Erler's probation is being extended by 90 days due to failure to meet standards and needing improvement, as reflected in his evaluation. | may have material in his personnel file subject to disclosure under Brady v. Maryland | potential disciplinary allegations | possible violation of conduct

Officer

Name
David Erler
POST ID
C42-F97 (name+agency)
Name in NPI
DAVID ERLER

Search within this case's documents →

Incidents 1

DateConductCategoryFindingDiscipline / outcome
2022-04-28 Failure to participate in, or giving false or misleading statements, or misrepresenting or omitting material information to a supervisor or other person of authority, in connection with any investigation; Criminal, dishonest, or disgraceful conduct; and other conduct unbecoming a member of this department. Specifically, Erler is alleged to have lied to a fire investigator about burning a stump and using an accelerant the night before a structure fire, and suggesting a neighbor's HVAC system was the cause. | Detective David Erler was involved in off-duty conduct which may be considered unbecoming of a member of this department or tends to reflect unfavorably upon this department or its members. Gave false or misleading statements or admitted material information to a person of authority in connection with an investigation. And committed conduct that was dishonest or disgraceful off duty that adversely effects the member's relationship with this department. | involved in off-duty conduct which may be considered unbecoming by a member of this department, or tends to reflect unfavorably upon this department or its members, gave false or misleading statements, or omitted material information to a person of authority in connection with an investigation, and committed conduct that was dishonest, or disgraceful off duty that adversely affects the member's relationship with this department. | Failure to participate in, or giving false or misleading statements, or misrepresenting or omitting material information to a supervisor or other person of authority; criminal, dishonest, or disgraceful conduct; and conduct unbecoming a member of the department, specifically regarding lying to a fire investigator and insurance adjuster about burning a stump that caused a structure fire. | Giving false or misleading statements, or misrepresenting or omitting material information to a supervisor or other person of authority, in connection with any investigation or in reporting or any department related business and dishonest or disgraceful conduct, whether on or off duty, that adversely affects the member's relationship with this department | you (Officer Erler at the time) took no notes while conducting a DUI investigation and then did not review your body worn camera footage to assist with preparation of the associated arrest report. Discrepancies were found between the official arrest report and what was captured on your body worn camera | Det. Erler is alleged to have denied his involvement with a fire, spread rumors about a neighbor's HVAC system as the cause, and been untruthful with Fire Investigator Sargent and Grange Insurance regarding the cause of the fire, specifically lying about burning a stump the night before. | Failed to make mention of his BWC being present or activated (it wasn't activated) and failed to complete a felony investigation for an explosive used to destroy a mailbox, instead telling suspects to return and repair it without asking the victim if they'd like to pursue prosecution. | Detective Erler provided misleading statements and omitted material information to a fire investigator and insurance adjuster regarding burning a stump and using an accelerant during a structure fire investigation, while suggesting a neighbor's HVAC system may have caused the fire. | took no notes while conducting a DUI investigation and then did not review your body worn camera footage to assist with preparation of the associated arrest report. Discrepancies were found between the official arrest report and what was captured on your body worn camera | Mr. Erler provided misleading information throughout when he indicated that the fire could have started from his neighbor's new AC unit and not being entirely truthful about burning a tree stump in his backyard, and indicated that he did lie to the Fire Investigator. | Poor report preparation (lacking detail and thoroughness), no reference to BWC being present or activated, no reference to attempting to obtain security footage or interview witnesses, and providing contradictory statements regarding receipt of emails from a victim. | you informed [Sergeant Mendenhall] that you had not received any email from the victim... Lieutenant Wright followed up with the victim asking for an email correspondence showing he had emailed you, which he did and was contrary to what you told Sergeant Mendenhall. | Detective Erler provided false and misleading statements to a fire investigator and insurance adjuster regarding a structure fire, denying he burned a palm tree stump and falsely suggesting a neighbor's HVAC system was the cause; he also denied using an accelerant. | The officer is alleged to have been burning a stump in his backyard the night before a fire occurred and subsequently failed to be honest and forthcoming about the cause of the fire, potentially telling coworkers it was caused by a neighbor's air conditioner. | Detective Erler provided false or misleading statements and omitted material information to a fire investigator, his supervisor, and an insurance adjuster regarding the burning of a palm tree stump and the use of an accelerant prior to a structure fire. | Officer Erler took no notes while conducting a DUI investigation and then did not review his body worn camera footage to assist with preparation of the associated arrest report, resulting in discrepancies between the report and the footage. | Detective Erler is alleged to have been untruthful to a Fire Investigator about burning a stump the night prior to a structure fire and continued to mislead others about the neighbor's HVAC system being the cause of the fire. | you informed [Sergeant Mendenhall] that you had not received any email from the victim... The victim sent Lieutenant Wright a copy of the email(s) in question, demonstrating that what you told Sergeant Mendenhall was false. | you informed [Sergeant Mendenhall] that you had not received any email from the victim. The victim sent Lieutenant Wright a copy of the email(s) in question, demonstrating that what you told Sergeant Mendenhall was false. | During a DUI investigation, failed to take notes, produced a report with several discrepancies compared to BWC footage, and failed to review his own BWC footage to aid in the writing and accuracy of his report. | Officer Erler falsely informed Sergeant Mendenhall that he had not received an email from a victim in an assault case, which was later proven false by the victim providing the emails to Lieutenant Wright. | Officer was burning a stump in his backyard at 9 o'clock at night; the fire was 'pretty big' and 'up over the fence', and the witness's house caught fire at 3 o'clock in the morning. | Mr Erler had lied numerous times about what may have been the cause [of a fire] and even stated it may have come from our home... he would lie multiple times to a fire investigator. | Officer Erler is alleged to have been untruthful during a fire investigation, initially denying he was burning a stump and suggesting a neighbor's HVAC system caused the fire. | concerns about the investigation and Detective Erler's involvement regarding a structure fire which occurred at Detective David Erler's residence and his neighbor's residence | Investigation regarding a structure fire at his residence and whether he was dishonest about the cause, specifically regarding lighting a stump on fire. | The ignition source of the fire was from intentional application of open flame for the purposes of stump removal, which extended to two structures. | Ofc. Erler's probation is being extended by 90 days due to failure to meet standards and needing improvement, as reflected in his evaluation. | may have material in his personnel file subject to disclosure under Brady v. Maryland | potential disciplinary allegations | possible violation of conduct —
FPPM 339.5.8(c) PERFORMANCE; FPPM 339.5.9(h) CONDUCT; FFPM 339.5.9(m) CONDUCT; City of Folsom Personnel Rules and Regulations Section 1.08.110 (B)(1), (B)(4), (C)(9) | FPPM 339.5.8(c) PERFORMANCE; FPPM 339.5.9(h) CONDUCT; FPPM 339.5.9(m) CONDUCT; Personnel Rules Section 1.08.110(B)(1), (4) and (C)(9) | FPPM 339.5.8(c) PERFORMANCE; FPPM 339.5.9(h) CONDUCT; FPPM 339.5.9(m) CONDUCT | 339.4 GENERAL STANDARDS; 339.5.7 EFFICIENCY; 343.1.1 REPORT PREPARATION; 343.3 GENERAL POLICY OF EXPEDITIOUS REPORTING; 437.4 ACTIVATION OF THE BODY-WORN CAMERA SYSTEM | 437.4 ACTIVATION OF THE BODY-WORN CAMERA SYSTEM | 343.1.1 REPORT PREPARATION | FPPM 339.5.9(h) Conduct; FPPM 339.5.9(m) Standards of Conduct | FPPM 339.5.8(c) PERFORMANCE; FPPM 339.5.9(h) CONDUCT; FPPM 339.5.9(m) CONDUCT; Section 1.08.110 (B)(1), (B)(4), (C)(9) | FPPM 339.5.8(c) PERFORMANCE; FPPM 339.5.9(h) CONDUCT; FPPM 339.5.9(m) CONDUCT; City of Folsom Personnel Rules and Regulations Section 1.08.110 (B)(1), (B)(4), (C)(9) | FPPM 339.5.8(c) PERFORMANCE; 339.5.9(h) CONDUCT; 339.5.9(m) CONDUCT
sustained
Allegation #1 (FPPM 339.5.8(c)): sustained; Allegation #2 (FPPM 339.5.9(h)): sustained; Allegation #3 (FPPM 339.5.9(m)): sustained
termination of employment | probation period was extended for three months | Termination from Employment | request to extend his probationary period for up to 90 days and withhold his merit increase | Modified work duty status; assigned to the records unit; not to function as a police officer or display a badge or weapon | probation is being extended by 90 days | Termination | probation period was extended for three months, from August 1, 2022, to November 1, 2022 | paid Administrative Leave
Evidence · quote found
ALLEGATION #1 FPPM 339 – STANDARDS OF CONDUCT 339.5.8(c) PERFORMANCE Failure to participate in, or giving false or misleading statements... Disposition: Sustained

Documents 32

agency investigation 16

DocumentKindDatePagesSourceLinked by
Folsom PD Interview Transcript of Fire Investigator Jeffery Sargent interview transcript — 16 Agency record
Folsom PD IA Interview Transcript: Sergeant J. Wagner (IA 24-004) interview transcript 2024 2 Agency record
Folsom PD IA Interview Transcript: Detective David Erler (IA 24-004) interview transcript 2024 6 Agency record
Insurance Claim Interview Transcript - David [REDACTED] (July 24, 2024) interview transcript 2024-07-24 7 Agency concern
Folsom PD Internal Affairs Investigation IA 24-004 investigation report 2024-09-27 47 Agency record
Folsom PD Internal Affairs Investigation Notification IA 24-004 (Detective David Erler) investigation notice 2024-09-30 1 Agency record
Folsom PD Internal Affairs Initiation Memo IA 24-002 investigation report 2024-10-02 1 Agency record
Folsom PD Interview Transcript - Neighbor of Dave Erler interview transcript 2024-10-08 7 Agency record
Folsom PD Interview Transcript - Witness regarding David Erler Structure Fire interview transcript 2024-10-08 6 Agency record
Folsom PD IA Interview Transcript: Sgt. John Wagner (IA 24-004) interview transcript 2024-10-09 7 Agency record
Folsom PD Witness Employee Admonition IA 24-004 (Sgt. John Wagner) investigation notice 2024-10-09 2 Agency record
Folsom PD Interview Transcript: Detective David Erler (IA 24-004) interview transcript 2024-11-06 29 Agency record
Folsom PD Internal Affairs Accused Employee Admonition - Detective David Erler (IA 24-004) investigation notice 2024-11-06 2 Agency record
Folsom PD Internal Affairs Investigation IA 24-004 (Detective David Erler) investigation report 2024-12-30 33 Agency record
Folsom PD Administrative Leave Memorandum - Detective David Erler investigation notice 2025 2 Agency record
Folsom PD Administrative Leave Memorandum - Detective David Erler investigation notice 2025-02-24 2 Agency record

criminal case 4

DocumentKindDatePagesSourceLinked by
Folsom PD Incident History #F24140131 police report 2024-07-24 4 Agency file
NFIRS Fire Report F24140131 police report 2024-07-24 14 Agency concern
Sacramento Metropolitan Fire District Fire Investigation Report 2024-000214 (Dave Erler) forensic report 2024-07-24 7 Agency record
Folsom Fire Department NFIRS Report F24140131 police report 2024-07-25 17 Agency concern

discipline and employment 10

evidence 2

DocumentKindDatePagesSourceLinked by
Text Message Screenshots between Officer and Dave regarding house fire photograph 2024-07-30 3 Agency concern
Folsom PD Email Complaint regarding Officer David Erler communications 2024-10-03 2 Agency record