Folsom PD Skelly Response Form - David Erler
About this document
- Layer
- agency record: part of a file an agency produced
- Type as titled
- skelly response form (kind from doc_type)
- Produced as
- folsom-police-department/IA 24-004 Final Release.pdf
- File
- c93848aa2bbdb41ec3ce59408815573609c88ef7 application/pdf
- Cases
About: David Erler (case)
- • Because of his state of mind during the aftermath early in the morning, Mr. Erler could not remember everything that was discussed with the Fire Investigator
- • The IA documentation did not include additional information/follow up provided by Mr. Erler to his home insurance company
- • He mentioned that Mr. Erler's investigation was not related to his job duties
- • He mentioned that Mr. Erler's did not purposely lie during the investigation
- • He mentioned that Mr. Erler answered many questions related to the fire and could not remember everything that was discussed during the interviews that were not recorded
- • Recommended that the discipline be fully revoked because there is not enough evidence (he stated circumstantial) to maintain the City's conclusion of "lying"
- • The incident and any related matters to the incident were not a result of "job performance" and therefore should not result in termination (or any discipline related to employment with Folsom PD)
- • He stated that other information provided verbally by him during the Skelly was not provided during the IA investigation (i.e. second phone call to Mr. Erler's insurance company, fire investigator's report, and that within 24 hours of the fire he told others that he was burning the stump)
Mr. Erler provided the following information:
- • He was not able to remember everything from his discussion with the Fire Investigator
- • He remembers the Fire Investigator being "upset" with him at some point during the interview the morning of the fire
- • He called the insurance company back a second time after the fire and recommended that a separate fire investigation by the insurance company be conducted
- • He has burned the stump in the past
- • He stated he only burned the stump that evening for a couple of minutes
- • He and his wife had an argument with their daughter that evening and stayed outside to discuss parenting and the stump was not burning during their discussion
- • He stated he does remember telling the fire investigator and the insurance company about the neighbor's new AC unit
I find that the proposed disciplinary action of termination of employment should remain in place. I base this on the following:
- • Violations of the Folsom Police Policy Manual, specifically FPPM 339.5.9(h) Conduct and FPPM 339.5.9(m) Standards of Conduct
As a sworn officer, Mr. Erler should understand that Folsom Police Department conduct is critical to maintaining the public trust and the trust of your department. While it is difficult to know whether or not Mr. Erler directly lied to anyone during the fire investigation or IA investigation, he did provide misleading information throughout when he indicated that the fire could have started from his neighbor's new AC unit and not being entirely truthful about burning a tree stump in his backyard. On several occasions Mr. Erler had the opportunity to inform someone that he was burning his tree stump the night before the fire started, but he continued to support his thoughts that the fire could have originated from the neighbor's new AC unit. One last item, during an interview on November 6, 2024 with Sergeant Roman Kehm and Sergeant Warner Herndon, Mr. Erler indicated that he did lie to the Fire Investigator (page 23 of the transcripts).
| Skelly Officer Signature: | Date: 5/9/2025 |
| CITY MANAGER'S OFFICE RESPONSE |
| Name: | Job Title: City Manager | Date: 5/12/25 |
Page 2 of 2
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.