Documents › c93848aa2bbdb41ec3ce59408815573609c88ef7:170-202

Folsom PD Internal Affairs Investigation IA 24-004 (Detective David Erler)

Agency records investigation reportagency investigation 2024-12-30 Folsom Police Department 33 pages (file pages 170–202) original file
About this document
Layer
agency record: part of a file an agency produced
Type as titled
ia investigation report (kind from doc_type)
Produced as
folsom-police-department/IA 24-004 Final Release.pdf
File
c93848aa2bbdb41ec3ce59408815573609c88ef7 application/pdf
Cases
agency:C-12b9c9bd93 · David Erler (record)

About: David Erler (case)

Page 31 · file page 200 larger image
Image of page 31; its text is alongside
Text: OCR

Memo

This is an example of Det. Erler being intentionally vague when answering certain direct questions. When he senses trouble, he seemingly cannot remember what was asked of him or what his answers were.

Several hours after the fire and the initial shock of this experience should have been diminished, Det. Erler called to report his loss to Grange Insurance. During this recorded telephone call, Det. Erler never once mentioned the burning stump as a possible cause of this fire, despite FI Sargent asking him repeated questions about the stump. The insurance representative (██████████) asked Det. Erler if they (the fire department or fire investigator) told him how the fire started, and Det. Erler initially responds, "No. I haven't. I haven't. I had talked to the investigator, but that was before he did his thing."

Later in his conversation with ██████████, Det. Erler says he thinks it is "very relevant" that his neighbor (██████████) had his HVAC system replaced the day before the fire. Det. Erler further elaborates, "Sometimes I know that. When you mess with electrical stuff, bad things can happen." ██████████ asked Det. Erler if he knew the name of the company that performed the HVAC work, and he said that he did not. Det. Erler further stated, "I think I explained it like. What I was told by the fire department is that the fire originated at their house and spread to our house." Before ending her conversation with Det. Erler, ██████████ asks if there's anything else he can think of. Det. Erler states there is not, and he mentions nothing about the stump burning.

During Det. Erler's IA interview, Sgt. Kehm attempted to break down the interview between FI Sargent and Det. Erler for clarity. Rather than answering the questions being asked of him to the best of his recollection, Det. Erler told Sgt. Kehm that he was getting caught up in the 'specificity' of the words that FI Sargent used.

One of the most relevant questions Sgt. Kehm asked Det. Erler during his interview, was if FI Sargent asked if he was burning the stump the night before the fire. And while this is a simple question, Det. Erler's response was as follows:

I don't – I don't know. Like I said, I – I believe he asked something similar to that during our conversation. I don't know specifically what – what words he said or how he phrased it, or when in our conversation he – he said that. I – I believe he did ask something very similar to that if – if not – I mean, and it wouldn't surprise me that he asked that question specifically. But I don't have the vivid memory of – of that specifically.

Page 31 of 33

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.