Folsom PD Internal Affairs Investigation IA 24-004 (Detective David Erler)
About this document
- Layer
- agency record: part of a file an agency produced
- Type as titled
- ia investigation report (kind from doc_type)
- Produced as
- folsom-police-department/IA 24-004 Final Release.pdf
- File
- c93848aa2bbdb41ec3ce59408815573609c88ef7 application/pdf
- Cases
About: David Erler (case)
Memo
when everyone is sound asleep. It is entirely possible that Det. Erler was so overcome with emotion after realizing the loss of his and his neighbor's homes that he was unable to think clearly, and this stress may have contributed to Det. Erler being less than immediately forthcoming with information when the fire investigator initially asked him if he knew how this fire could have started.
However, the records, statements, and application of reasoning support a conclusion that Det. Erler gave intentionally misleading, incomplete, or false information and/or omitted relevant facts during his interview with Fire Investigator Sargent and later with Grange Insurance Representative [REDACTED] on the morning of the fire, July 24, 2024. Furthermore, Det. Erler continued spreading misinformation while omitting pertinent details about the fire when he spoke with Sgt. Koupal and Sgt. Wagner. This includes Det. Erler's relentless theory that the neighbor's HVAC system was the possible cause of this fire while omitting his burning of the stump adjacent to the neighbor's fence merely six hours before both house fires.
This misinformation was so rampant that the neighbor ([REDACTED]) was compelled to confront Det. Erler about it for fear that ignoring it could drive a wedge between the two police departments they each worked for. When he was confronted in a text message, Det. Erler lied to [REDACTED] about spreading any misinformation about the cause of the fire.
During his IA interview, Det. Erler said his mind was on other things, so he couldn't remember everything asked or even some of his answers when FI Sargent interviewed him. While he obviously had a lot on his mind, being questioned by a fire investigator to determine the cause of this fire and Det. Erler's personal knowledge of burning the stump the night before the house fires should have stood out to him. Furthermore, Det. Erler should have been hyper focused on these questions and recognized that he was potentially liable for the cause of this fire. It is inconceivable that this specific line of questioning wouldn't have stood out in Det. Erler's mind, given the gravity of the situation and his obvious culpability. Any reasonable person would conclude that this line of questioning specific to the causation of the fire was significant, if not memorable.
During his IA interview, Det. Erler said he did not remember FI Sargent asking him about the stump the night before the fire, but he acknowledges that at some point, he must have misspoken or lied or told him something that was un-factual because FI Sargent said something to make him snap back into their conversation and start paying very close
Page 29 of 33
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.