Folsom PD Internal Affairs Investigation IA 24-004 (Detective David Erler)
About this document
- Layer
- agency record: part of a file an agency produced
- Type as titled
- ia investigation report (kind from doc_type)
- Produced as
- folsom-police-department/IA 24-004 Final Release.pdf
- File
- c93848aa2bbdb41ec3ce59408815573609c88ef7 application/pdf
- Cases
About: David Erler (case)
Memo
information about the stump he burned the night before (literally six hours prior to the fire) could have caused the house fires. Det. Erler admits loosely to burning the stump in his backyard two days prior to the fire. He then finally admits to burning the stump the night before the fire, but only after being confronted by FI Sargent about being less than truthful with him, and, after learning that FI Sargent had already spoken with his neighbors ([REDACTED] and [REDACTED]) about a large fire near their shared neighbor fence the night before the house fires.
As with his interview with FI Sargent, Det. Erler conveniently omitted the fact that he was burning a stump the night before the house fires, when he spoke with Rep. [REDACTED] from Grange Insurance – hours after the house fires, and his initial interview with the fire investigator. When [REDACTED] asked Det. Erler if he had any idea about how the fire was started, he told her, "No." Det. Erler later told [REDACTED] about the neighbor's recently installed HVAC system, offering this as a possible cause, stating, "Sometimes when you mess with electrical stuff, bad things can happen." Perhaps most troublesome about his conversation with [REDACTED] is the fact that this occurred well after his interview with FI Sargent that same day. After being accused (by a fire investigator) of being less than truthful about burning the stump the night before the fire, a reasonable person would have to conclude that this information was relevant to the overall fire investigation and should have been disclosed to the insurance adjuster as a potential cause of the fire, similar to the new HVAC unit.
To a Person of Authority –
Fire Investigator Sargent says in his interview and documents in his official fire incident report that he introduced himself to Det. Erler the morning of the house fires, as a Fire Investigator with the Sacramento Metro Fire District. And Det. Erler in his IA interview with Sgt. Kehm acknowledged that he was contacted by FI Sargent the morning of the fire. It is clear from Det. Erler's interview and his recollection of his interaction with FI Sargent at the scene of the house fire, that Det. Erler was aware of FI Sargent's authority to investigate the cause of this fire, and that he was in fact attempting to do that, through his specific line of questioning. Furthermore, during his IA interview when Sgt. Herndon attempted to clarify that FI Sargent asked him about burning the stump the night before, Det. Erler said, "I'm sure he asked me, when did you last burn the stump. I'm sure he did based upon him being a fire investigator and trying to investigate a fire."
Later the morning of the fire, Det. Erler spoke with [REDACTED] [REDACTED] from Grange Insurance to report the loss to his home. It is common knowledge that any insurance company is going to ask specific questions as to the causation of a fire when investigating
Page 24 of 33
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.