Folsom PD Internal Affairs Investigation IA 24-004 (Detective David Erler)
About this document
- Layer
- agency record: part of a file an agency produced
- Type as titled
- ia investigation report (kind from doc_type)
- Produced as
- folsom-police-department/IA 24-004 Final Release.pdf
- File
- c93848aa2bbdb41ec3ce59408815573609c88ef7 application/pdf
- Cases
About: David Erler (case)
Memo
closer to -- attention to what he was saying. I shouldn't have, you know, blown him off. Um -- again -- um -- what -- what was going through my mind was not to be dishonest or -- or misleading to him. I was trying to give him truthful information. I was confused during part of the infor -- interview. Um -- I had, you know, other things -- like I've -- we've talked about on my mind. As far as the -- the -- your -- your question about the HVAC thing, I believe I've said this already, I didn't believe that my actions with the stump caused this fire at the time. And as an investigator, I was grasping at straws trying to figure out how my house burned down, and how my neighbor's house burned down. Um -- I had overheard a firefighter say, you know, it looked like it possibly -- your house possibly caught on fire from their house. Okay. I had overheard, you know, someone say they heard, you know, an explosion maybe coming from where their HVAC system was. Again, I wasn't trying to say as a matter of fact I -- I know this -- this occurred. It was, okay, well what happened. I don't know, maybe it was this, but I don't -- but I don't know. And I certainly didn't want people saying that as like a matter of fact. It was -- it was just my -- my thoughts. And I've since gone to several people and said, look, that's not what happened. Their AC unit didn't blow up. There wasn't an electrical thing from their HVAC. It wasn't -- it wasn't that. Uh -- you know, I -- but again, at the time with everything that was going on in my mind, and I'm just, again, I wasn't thinking a hundred percent clearly. But I was like, oh, yeah, that HVAC truck was parked out front. They got a new HVAC yesterday. So, that's where my mind went is like, oh, maybe that was the cause. Not that was the cause, but maybe.
Sgt. Herndon confirmed that Det. Erler went back and told his insurance adjuster that it was not the HVAC and asked what made him make that determination.
Det. Erler said that a fire investigator from Grange Insurance came out to his house and told Det. Erler that the burn patterns originated in and around where the stump was. Det. Erler said he thanked the insurance investigator for telling him that and he estimated that this occurred about a week after the house fire.
Sgt. Herndon then asked Det. Erler if he viewed the fire investigator as a 'professional' in his field. At this point, Attorney Sean Howell interjected to clarify if Sgt. Herndon was talking about the fire investigator from Grange Insurance or from the night of the fire. Sgt. Herndon confirmed that he was speaking about FI Sargent. Det Erler said that when FI Sargent introduced himself, he began by saying that he was a retired deputy from El Dorado County and hadn't been a fire investigator for very long. Det. Erler then stated:
But I believe that when one of the -- one of his questions is do you know how this might
Page 18 of 33
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.