Documents › c79e0e4555d81c581de95c2ba65e73ed2a56d74b:235-248

-807- - BR09_POST2505112_Smithmatungol Kevin_Att.H_Administrative Interview Transcript 24-07.pdf

POST board interview transcriptagency investigation 2026-09-17 14 pages (file pages 235–248) original file
About this document
Layer
packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
Type as titled
transcript (kind from title)
File
c79e0e4555d81c581de95c2ba65e73ed2a56d74b application/pdf
Cases
POST 2505112 · Kevin Smithmatungol (packet item)

About: Kevin Smithmatungol (case)

Page 2 · file page 236 larger image
Image of page 2; its text is alongside
Text: digital text layer
DCPD Administrative Interview 
 
2 
 
 
Ciucci Recording. Okay. So it is Friday, January 31st, approximately 1105 hours am, sorry. Um, this is 
1 
Sergeant Ciucci, currently in the Daly City Police Department Professional Standards Unit office, with 
2 
me is Officer Kevin Smithmatungol. Kevin, if you could please say hi.  
3 
 
4 
Smithmatungol Hello.  
5 
 
6 
Ciucci Thank you. And, uh, you have, uh, your retained counsel with you, who is Mrs. Julia Fox from 
7 
Rains, Lucia, and Stern. If you wouldn't mind saying hello?  
8 
 
9 
Fox Sure. Julia Fox. 
10 
 
11 
Ciucci Perfect. Um, officer Smithmatungol, you are in here as a subject officer, uh, for Internal Affairs 
12 
investigation, 24-07. Uh, um, I'm gonna read you the administrative admonishment. If at any time 
13 
during the reading this admonishment, if there's anything you don't understand, please ask me and 
14 
we can get you the clarification that you need, all right?  Um, you are hereby advised that an 
15 
administrative investigation is in process within this department in which it has become necessary to 
16 
obtain a statement from you. If you cooperate fully at this time, your statements and any evidence 
17 
arising there from may be used in any and all proceedings arising out of this investigation. As a citizen 
18 
and an employee of this department, you're hereby advised that if prior to or during the taking of your 
19 
statement, this department determines that you may be charged with a criminal offense, the 
20 
proceeding will be stopped, and you will be advised of your constitutional rights and given an 
21 
opportunity to obtain legal counsel.  If you decide not to give a statement at this time, you're now 
22 
ordered as an employee of this department to answer all questions asked by investigators and to give 
23 
a full, detailed, and complete statement regarding your knowledge of or involvement in the matter now 
24 
under investigation.  Although you have a right to silence in criminal investigations, this is not a 
25 
criminal investigation, but an administrative hearing and you're now being ordered to tell all, excuse 
26 
me, to answer all questions under the compulsion of threat of disciplinary action. False statements, of 
27 
course, will result in severe disciplinary action. Members are always required to be truthful. Please 
28 
see Daly City Police Department Manual Rules 4.96, which is truthfulness. I'm gonna go ahead and 
29 
hand you this admonishment and I'll show you the last sentence, which says, I have read the above 
30 
admonishment order and I fully understand my rights and duties in this investigation. Please look it 
31 
over and if comfortable, please sign the bottom and date and time. Mrs. Fox, if can ask you to be the 
32 
witness.  
33 
 
34 
Ciucci Beautiful. Thank you. All right, so we're gonna dive in. Reminder, I'm an independent fact 
35 
finder. I'm just here to get your statement. I'm here to get all the facts and then I present it to the chief, 
36 
it's given to a lieutenant, and they do the findings and recommendations. So today, this is just an 
37 
interview, okay? Um, please be truthful about everything I ask and we'll begin here. Um, so on Friday, 
38 
October 25th, 2024, uh, you were working your B graveyard shift when you were given two citizen 
39 
subpoenas to serve. Does this sound familiar?  
40 
 
41 
Smithmatungol Yes.  
42 
 
43 
Ciucci There is hesitancy when you say yes.  Um, explain to me why you have a little hesitancy in 
44 
your voice when you said yes.  
45 
 
46 
Smithmatungol That exact date and, uh, we get subpoenas almost, almost every day. I mean, I dunno 
47 
those two exact subpoenas, I don't know the names on. I don't remember. It's October.  
48 
 
49 
Ciucci Let's do this. I have copies of two subpoenas that I'm gonna walk over to you. I labeled one, 
50 
uh, for defendant 
 as attachment one, and I've labeled one for defendant 
 as, uh, 
51 
attachment two. Okay. I'm gonna walk these over so we can all look at 'em together. Okay. So here 
52 
we go. Uh, attachment one is gonna be for 
 attachment two for 
 And what we'll do 
53 
here is I just kind of want to go through these together with both you. Uh, okay. Uh, I know based on 
54 
my understanding of Daly City, uh, uh, both, uh, policy as well as just our practice, that in briefing the 
55 
sergeant or their designee goes ahead and hands out the subpoenas. Is that also your 
56 

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.