Documents › c79e0e4555d81c581de95c2ba65e73ed2a56d74b:139-176

-807- - BR012_POST2505112_Smithmatungol Kevin_Att.K_Division Interview Transcript.pdf

POST board interview transcriptagency investigation 2026-09-17 38 pages (file pages 139–176) original file
About this document
Layer
packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
Type as titled
transcript (kind from title)
File
c79e0e4555d81c581de95c2ba65e73ed2a56d74b application/pdf
Cases
POST 2505112 · Kevin Smithmatungol (packet item)

About: Kevin Smithmatungol (case)

Page 15 · file page 153 larger image
Image of page 15; its text is alongside
Text: digital text layer
POST Administrative Interview 
 
15 
 
1 
Smithmatungol  Um, after, I mean, after I looked at the call and how I handled it, it wasn't the 
2 
appropriate way of handling it, and I just didn't take responsibility and I messed up.  
3 
 
4 
Moore What would've been the appropriate way to handle it? 
5 
 
6 
Smithmatungol  Take her to jail and do the right thing.  
7 
 
8 
Ganz Okay. Just why was it the wrong thing? Like just go into more now, like why do you feel that 
9 
way? 
10 
 
11 
Smithmatungol  I, I, I just felt that she, so she was pregnant. I saw that she was pregnant. What she 
12 
stole was, um, household items, food, and maybe some decor, not, not the consistent, um, shoplifters 
13 
that we tend to see, which steel buckets and buckets of tide pods, for example, to sell on the streets. 
14 
So I kind of also felt consciously bad that she's very, she's very, uh, physically looked like she's 
15 
pregnant. And so I just didn't think she was a, a habitual shoplifter. Target security is usually very, uh, 
16 
knowledgeable about who's a frequent, who's not. And they didn't tell me this is, she's been in here 
17 
multiple times. And I just kind of played that into effect and I, I, I, I felt bad for her. Um, and so that's, 
18 
that's why I cited and released her, but the right thing would've been take her to jail and go through 
19 
the process.  
20 
 
21 
Moore So the question right before this, I asked, can you please explain your decision process for 
22 
citing and releasing it? And you indicated that it was just because of beat accountability. Um, so let 
23 
me ask that question again. Uh, so with what you've brought forward, correct. Now it's a humanistic 
24 
approach, so there's two reasons. Is there any other reasons why, besides the humanity approach as 
25 
far as the subject and a beat accountability? Any other reasons?  
26 
 
27 
Smithmatungol  For that, I believe there was another shoplifter at the same time while I was dealing 
28 
with this one who was more aggressive verbally, um, verbally aggressive towards security as well as 
29 
just, I was shocked that he'd steal with the police car parked right out front, inside or outside. And so I 
30 
think I was just juggling her plus him. Um, and so I, I I might have gotten kind of jumbled. Um, but I, I 
31 
think that's it. I'm trying to recall it. Sorry.  
32 
 
33 
Moore Okay. Uh, we'll get into a little more detail about the second shoplifter, but before we get there, 
34 
did you and Officer Rodriguez have a discussion about fingerprinting her, fingerprinting her at any 
35 
time?  
36 
 
37 
Smithmatungol  I,I don't think so. I don't remember.  
38 
 
39 
Moore How about after this incident, did you have any discussions with him after everything's said 
40 
and done at any point between then and now regarding fingerprinting? For example, if after your IA 
41 
you're like, oh, did we fingerprint? Maybe, maybe not. At any point did you have a conversation with 
42 
Officer Rodriguez regarding fingerprinting?  
43 
 
44 
Smithmatungol  I, I think I did. I, or I think that day I asked him if I gave him a citation with the 
45 
fingerprint, and I think that's all I asked him for.  
46 
 
47 
Moore When was that conversation?  
48 
 
49 
Smithmatungol  I think that same day.  
50 
 
51 
Moore So after shift before shift in the middle of shift  
52 
 
53 
Smithmatungol  In the middle of the shift.  
54 
 
55 
Moore Uh, had you already concluded that scene?  
56 
 
57 
Smithmatungol  Yes. That was already done. I think this was hours after, hours later. Um, I was 
58 
confront, I was approached by my sergeant about the case, and I, I, I asked him if I gave him a 
59 
citation with a fingerprint. And--  
60 

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.