Documents › c79e0e4555d81c581de95c2ba65e73ed2a56d74b:117-138

-807- - BR01_POST2505112_Smithmatungol Kevin_ISF.pdf

POST board investigative summaryboard proceeding 2026-09-17 22 pages (file pages 117–138) original file
About this document
Layer
packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
Type as titled
isf (kind from doc_type)
File
c79e0e4555d81c581de95c2ba65e73ed2a56d74b application/pdf
Cases
POST 2505112 · Kevin Smithmatungol (packet item)

About: Kevin Smithmatungol (case)

Page 21 · file page 137 larger image
Image of page 21; its text is alongside
Text: digital text layer
 
      Investigative Summary and Recommendation 
 
 
Kevin Smithmatungol 
 
 
Case Number 
POST2505112/POST2505137/POST2505140 
Page 21 
     
 
he was busy with a Domestic Violence call that had led to an arrest, and he “And 
so I, I just put a time and date and no answer just to give it to the next team.  And 
I, I just didn’t want to get in trouble.”82 
o Note:  The Respondent indicated he observed “a handful” of officers 
indicate “No answer” on the subpoena return slip when they had not 
attempted to physically serve the subpoena. 
• During the interview with the Division, the Respondent explained, for the second 
subpoena, he wrote on the subpoena return slip that he attempted to serve it 
when had not because, “Same as the last one.  Um, I didn’t wanna get in trouble 
and I thought the next team could serve it.”83 
• During the interview with the Division, the Respondent was asked why he stated 
in his Internal Affairs interview that he had attempted to serve both subpoenas 
when he had not, and the Respondent stated, “I, I don’t know why I did that.  It 
was untruthful and I had no reason to.”84 
• During the interview with the Division, the Respondent was asked why he said 
during his Internal Affairs interview that GPS would show him at the two 
addresses listed on the subpoenas, when he had not attempted to serve either 
subpoena, and the Respondent stated, “Um, I dunno why I did, but it was 
untruthful.”  The Respondent further explained, “…that IA I was, I was nervous.  
Um, my first, that was my first IA meeting.  And that’s, I was scared.”  The 
Respondent’s counsel asked, “Were you hoping that you would basically get 
away with that lie and not get in trouble? Was that what, was that your thought 
process at the time?” and the Respondent stated, “Yeah.”85 
• During the interview with the Division, the Respondent admitted when he stated 
during his Internal Affairs interview that he attempted the serve the subpoenas 
when he had not, he was dishonest and he did not demonstrate integrity.  The 
Respondent explained, “Um, I try to excuse myself and not want to get in trouble. 
In trouble.  And so instead of confronting the issue head on at the time it 
happened, I try to work my way around it and it was not the right thing to do.  It 
questions, I mean, it makes assumptions of who I am and who I am as a person, 
which I’m, I’m not, I mean, I hope I’m not, but now that my name is tarnished and 
the department’s tarnished, and um, sorry, it’s, it just questions my integrity.”86  
 
Reasonable grounds exist to submit this case to the Peace Officer Standards 
Accountability Advisory Board and the POST Commission for consideration of 
revocation or suspension pursuant to California Penal Code section 13510.8. 
 
82 Attachment K – Division Interview Transcript – page 32, lines 33-48.  
83 Attachment K – Division Interview Transcript – page 34, lines 9-10. 
84 Attachment K – Division Interview Transcript – page 34, lines 12-18. 
85 Attachment K – Division Interview Transcript – page 34, lines 25-45. 
86 Attachment K – Division Interview Transcript – page 35, lines 30-34. 

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.