Documents › c79e0e4555d81c581de95c2ba65e73ed2a56d74b:117-138

-807- - BR01_POST2505112_Smithmatungol Kevin_ISF.pdf

POST board investigative summaryboard proceeding 2026-09-17 22 pages (file pages 117–138) original file
About this document
Layer
packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
Type as titled
isf (kind from doc_type)
File
c79e0e4555d81c581de95c2ba65e73ed2a56d74b application/pdf
Cases
POST 2505112 · Kevin Smithmatungol (packet item)

About: Kevin Smithmatungol (case)

Page 9 · file page 125 larger image
Image of page 9; its text is alongside
Text: digital text layer
 
      Investigative Summary and Recommendation 
 
 
Kevin Smithmatungol 
 
 
Case Number 
POST2505112/POST2505137/POST2505140 
Page 9 
     
 
• He initially told his partner he was going to book the subject because there was 
no other way to identify her; however, then he told his partner he was going to 
cite her because they were short staff that day and stressed the importance of 
beat accountability. 
• He related he made a “bad judgement call”13 when he cited and released the 
subject and he should have taken her to jail. 
• He indicated the subject appeared pregnant, he did not feel she was a habitual 
shoplifter, and he felt bad for her. 
• At the time of the investigation, a second shoplifter was detained, he confirmed 
his identity by name and date of birth, to a matching California Identification 
number, which he confirmed by photo. 
• When asked why he told his supervisor he obtained a fingerprint from the subject 
he stated, “Um, I panicked. I, I have no excuse for what I did. I just, I just 
panicked.  I, that was my first kind of getting in trouble doing something wrong, 
and I didn’t take accountability for myself. And I have no excuse for that one.”14 
• When asked why he claimed in his Internal Affairs interview that he obtained a 
fingerprint from the subject he stated, “Um, I, like I said, I have no excuse. I was 
going through some personal things then, and I, I have no reason.”15 
• He reviewed his BWC prior to his Internal Affairs interview, was aware he should 
have booked the subject when he was unable to identify her, and decided to not 
be forthcoming with that information during his Internal Affairs interview.  When 
asked why, he stated, “I don’t have any excuses. Um, that that was my first kind 
of disciplining and as well as some things back at home and, or something 
happening at home and I just wasn’t in the right mindset and I didn’t take 
responsibility for my actions.”16 
• He admitted he was dishonest in his Internal Affairs interview. 
• He agreed with the findings and recommendations by DCPD and stated, “Um, I, 
it’s appropriate and I messed up.  I didn’t take accountability and I don’t deserve 
to be a department that would have your back if you can’t even do the right thing. 
And so whatever they did was appropriate and that’s why I didn’t fight it during 
the Skelly. I just wanted to take it head on.”17 
• He indicated he had no evidence to refute the findings of dishonesty. 
 
 
 
 
 
13 Attachment K – Division Interview Transcript – page 14, line 58 - page 13, line 7. 
14 Attachment K – Division Interview Transcript – page 17, lines 29-31. 
15 Attachment K – Division Interview Transcript – page 17, lines 36-37. 
16 Attachment K – Division Interview Transcript – page 19, lines 22-24.  
17 Attachment K – Division Interview Transcript – page 19, lines 55-58. 

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.