Documents › c79e0e4555d81c581de95c2ba65e73ed2a56d74b:117-138

-807- - BR01_POST2505112_Smithmatungol Kevin_ISF.pdf

POST board investigative summaryboard proceeding 2026-09-17 22 pages (file pages 117–138) original file
About this document
Layer
packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
Type as titled
isf (kind from doc_type)
File
c79e0e4555d81c581de95c2ba65e73ed2a56d74b application/pdf
Cases
POST 2505112 · Kevin Smithmatungol (packet item)

About: Kevin Smithmatungol (case)

Page 7 · file page 123 larger image
Image of page 7; its text is alongside
Text: digital text layer
 
      Investigative Summary and Recommendation 
 
 
Kevin Smithmatungol 
 
 
Case Number 
POST2505112/POST2505137/POST2505140 
Page 7 
     
 
shoplifting, based on the name and date of birth provided.  The Respondent also cited 
and released the second subject; however, the male subject provided his name and 
date of birth.  A records check revealed the male subject’s California Identification 
number, and the Respondent confirmed his identity via photographic records. 
 
The Respondent’s field supervisor reviewed the Respondent’s report and returned it to 
him for corrections, indicating the Respondent failed to document how or if the female 
suspect was identified.  That evening, the Respondent spoke with his supervisor 
regarding the requested corrections, explained he thought suspects could be issued 
citations without being positively identified, and spontaneously stated he had obtained 
the suspect’s fingerprint.  After confirming that the Respondent had not obtained a 
digital fingerprint from the subject, as the electronic ticket writer the Respondent used 
that day did not have the capabilities of obtaining a digital fingerprint, and after 
reviewing the BWC recordings from the incident,5 on or about June 8, 2024, the 
supervisor confronted the Respondent that it appeared he had not obtained a fingerprint 
from the subject.  The Respondent stated at the conclusion of his detention, he walked 
the subject to his patrol vehicle where he printed a duplicate copy of the citation, 
retrieved an ink pad, and fingerprinted the subject.  The supervisor again asked if he 
was sure he obtained a fingerprint, to which the Respondent stated yes and indicated 
he would check his duty bag for the physical copy, but then reported to his supervisor 
he was unable to locate it.  The supervisor obtained the surveillance footage from 
Target, which displayed no evidence to substantiate a fingerprint was obtained.6  As a 
result of the suspected dishonest statements, an Internal Affairs investigation (24-04) 
was initiated.   
 
On January 31, 2025, the Respondent participated in an Internal Affairs interview 
related to the identification of the suspect and the statements made to his supervisor.  
During the Internal Affairs interview, the Respondent made the following statements:7 
• When asked if he obtained a fingerprint of the female subject, the Respondent 
stated, “I did.”8 
• When asked when the fingerprint was obtained, the Respondent stated, “…so I 
gave her the citation when she was sitting down in the security office, uh, briefly 
went out or gave her the citation while she was in the office,” and further 
explained, “Um, got everything I needed from security.  She walked out to go find 
a friend that she was with at the initial time of call that’s when the security officer 
said that there’s two of them, one of them already left.  She went to go find her 
friend or something like that because she went back into the Target store and 
 
5 Attachment C – Administrative Investigative Memorandum Excerpts (24-04) – page 2. 
6 Attachment C – Administrative Investigative Memorandum Excerpts (24-04) –pages 3-4. 
7 Attachment D – Administrative Interview Transcript (24-04). 
8 Attachment D – Administrative Interview Transcript (24-04) – page 5, line 39. 

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.