Documents › aae5d7ee626933e30e42fc35b4747f43f84e4d78:1-83

POSAAB Meeting Transcript January 16, 2025

POST board hearing transcriptboard proceeding 2025-01-16 83 pages (file pages 1–83) original file
About this document
Layer
attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
Type as titled
board hearing transcript (kind from doc_type)
File
aae5d7ee626933e30e42fc35b4747f43f84e4d78 application/pdf
Cases
POST 2309558 · Braulio Robledo (filed under case)

About: Braulio Robledo (case)

Page 52 · file page 52 larger image
Image of page 52; its text is alongside
Text: OCR

POSAAB Meeting, January 16, 2025

1 But as a matter of law, it is perfectly legal to
2 ask a person during a consensual contact or in a vehicle
3 stop; it is a detention based on reasonable suspicion.
4 The reasonable suspicion being the expired registration.

5 It can be done, even in the absence of any
6 particularized suspicion. That's the -- that's the
7 nature of the law on -- on that.

8 CHAIRPERSON DUDLEY: I don't think the question has
9 been, can you ask for consent?

10 The question has been: In situations like this,
11 where someone has an expired registration, does that
12 compel you to ask you for consent? Anybody can ask
13 consent about anything.

14 Do you understand the distinction?

15 MEMBER LARA: Yes. I just -- I thought it would be
16 useful to understand that there's -- there's nothing
17 untoward in asking.

18 MEMBER CLAVO: And I didn't think that.

19 CHAIRPERSON DUDLEY: I know. Yeah.

20 Okay. Yes.

21 MEMBER HATCHER-CRAWFORD: And I think, to go along
22 with Board Member Nicole, as he said, routinely that he
23 will search -- ask permission to search a car based on
24 expired tags. That's concerning to me.

25 I mean, I know you were polite, Board Member

229

KATHRYN S. SWANK, CSR, RPR (916) 390-7731

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.