Documents › a08af50d4cb71291ce26573f357d57f47ca4f808:1-13

Daly City Notice of Intent to Terminate Kevin Smithmatungol

POST board disciplinediscipline and employment 2025-06-02 13 pages (file pages 1–13) original file
About this document
Layer
attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
Type as titled
notice of intent to terminate (kind from doc_type)
File
a08af50d4cb71291ce26573f357d57f47ca4f808 application/pdf
Cases
POST 2505112 · Kevin Smithmatungol (filed under case)

About: Kevin Smithmatungol (case)

Page 4 · file page 4 larger image
Image of page 4; its text is alongside
Text: OCR

A. JUNE 2, 2024 – (IA #24-04) SERRAMONTE TARGET ARREST

On June 2, 2024, at approximately 7:45pm, you responded to Target, 133 Serramonte Center, on the report of a detained shoplifter. During the investigation you determined the subject, a female, did not have any form of valid identification and you were unable to confirm her identity. As a result, you acknowledged your intent to process her at the county jail as opposed to issuing a citation for the misdemeanor arrest, which was captured in your body camera footage. You stated twice, “I’m gonna book her then,” after learning she had no valid identification. At the conclusion of the petty theft detention, you elected to cite the female out and release her from the store instead of booking her, without first seeking supervisor approval. Your reasoning for your decision to cite as opposed to booking the female into jail was not consistent. While on-scene you stated you were going to book her, but then a short time later you told Officer Rodriguez, your cover officer, “We’re short, I’m just gonna cite her.”

Later that same evening, Sergeant Karen Douglas electronically returned your investigative police report to you for corrections, and you initiated contact with her about the investigation. You told Sergeant Douglas that you identified the subject from a bank credit card she had and Sergeant Douglas explained to you that doing so was an insufficient method of identifying someone, as the credit card could have belonged to someone else. Sergeant Douglas asked you why you did not book her, and you responded that the subject was in her late stages of pregnancy, and you did not want to have to take her to “Chope” Hospital for a medical clearance prior to being booked into jail. Sergeant Douglas asked you if the subject had a local address or if she provided a phone number. You said the subject told you she was staying at a homeless shelter but did not know the address and you did not obtain a phone number from her. Sergeant Douglas reminded you about proper processing of someone you could not identify, which she noted was also communicated during team briefings, of which you said you were still unaware of. You then offered up that you obtained a thumbprint for the subject on the citation before releasing her. Sergeant Douglas responded, “Oh great, you did?” to which you then responded in the affirmative.

On June 8, 2024, Sergeant Douglas and Sergeant Jerel Tualaulelei met with you to discuss other performance concerns and a lack of self-initiated proactivity. During this meeting they again asked about the citation from the Target arrest case, as it had yet to be turned in even though you said you had previously placed it on the sergeant’s desk to be forwarded. Sergeant Douglas told you it appeared that you had not obtained the suspect’s thumbprint to which you responded that you did obtain it. You then claimed that you attempted to use your citation writer to obtain the print but that it was not working. Sergeant Douglas also noted during this conversation that your electronic ticket writer did not have the digital thumbprint capability, at which time you said you obtained an ink print, noting you walked the subject to your patrol car to obtain an ink print on a duplicate ticket before releasing her. You were uncertain as to the location of the citation and were given an opportunity to produce it. When asked if you were sure you obtained the thumbprint, you immediately responded in the affirmative. A short time later you located several citations from your patrol bag, but this specific citation was not one of them.

4

12904989.1 DA003-026

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.