Documents › 823ce8c459a82ee26139c1c42fd7f4d750c7368d:1-10

Daly City Police Department Administrative Interview Transcript - Kevin Smithmatungol

POST board interview transcriptagency investigation 2025-01-31 10 pages (file pages 1–10) original file
About this document
Layer
attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
Type as titled
ia interview transcript (kind from doc_type)
File
823ce8c459a82ee26139c1c42fd7f4d750c7368d application/pdf
Cases
POST 2505112 · Kevin Smithmatungol (filed under case)

About: Kevin Smithmatungol (case)

Page 9 · file page 9 larger image
Image of page 9; its text is alongside
Text: OCR

DCPD Administrative Interview

1 Ciucci Okay. Um, at any time did you lie to your Sergeant, Sergeant Douglas during the course of
2 your explanation for, uh, either why you did not cite, or excuse me, take, uh, the female subject to jail
3 or how you identified her or how you did the thumbprint? Did you ever lie once to your sergeant?

4
5 Smithmatungol No, I told her exactly what I told you.

6
7 Ciucci Okay. Um, in your earlier answer, you said that you weren't aware of the, of the policy. Have
8 you a chance to review policy 420 of Lexipol, uh, that outlines when and why you should, uh, go
9 ahead and cite somebody out?

10
11 Smithmatungol I read it, but I don't know verbatim.

12
13 Ciucci Don't know verbatim. I don't expect you to, there's about 3000 policies. Okay. Um, are you
14 aware if the person cannot provide satisfactory evidence of personal identification, they cannot be
15 cited out?

16
17 Smithmatungol Yep.

18
19 Ciucci Okay. Um, are you aware that there's also a penal code that does the exact same thing that is
20 the basis essentially for that policy?

21
22 Smithmatungol Penal code, no, but policy, yes.

23
24 Ciucci okay. Um, the penal code is 853.6. It outlines when somebody can be, uh, cited out and when
25 they can't. Um, sitting in this office now is never a comfortable feeling for anybody.

26
27 Smithmatungol No, sir.

28
29 Ciucci Um, in hindsight, looking back at the situation, uh, if you were to have the benefit of, of that
30 hindsight, was there anything you would change or do differently?

31
32 Smithmatungol Um, I would've got, went with my gut. I mean, I said I was gonna book her before any
33 of that thing happened. I should have booked her, I should have got sergeant approval if I was gonna
34 cite her. Um, I didn't think she was a prolific shoplifter. Target had no history with her. She stole
35 household goods. It wasn't like a laundry pods or anything. It was like a household plant. It was a
36 clock. So I, she appeared pregnant too. She had the distended belly. I believe she was pregnant and
37 like when she stood up, you can see the big rounding of her stomach. I, at that time, I didn't think it
38 was excess fat. It looked to me pregnancy. I thought I was just being a good person. Maybe she was
39 down on some luck. I thought I should have gave a citation and let her go home. But in the end I
40 should have booked her. I should have done sergeant's approval. Um, I did make mistakes and I
41 haven't had an issue of the same sort since.

42
43 Ciucci Okay. Um, is there anything that I did not ask you that you feel is important for me to
44 understand or know in regards to the reasoning behind any of this, giving me, providing me with any
45 context or?

46
47 Smithmatungol Uh, I might have gotten a little confused sometimes with the two shoplift things at the
48 same time, I wanted to be a good beat partner and handle my, my, uh, beat, uh, without anyone
49 having to take paper from me, but sometimes it's better to ask for help.

50
51 Ciucci Okay.

52
53 Fox Good. That's the only thing I was gonna follow up on. Did the fact that there was this intervening
54 48 on the part of the black male adult sort of throw you off the rhythm of this particular investigation?

55
56 Smithmatungol Yeah, just because his aggression with one officer out there, I wanted to finish with
57 her as quick as possible so I can be a good partner out there in case something does go wrong, it'd
58 be my fault.

59

9

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.