Supplement to Investigative Summary and Findings - Michael Kim
About this document
- Layer
- attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
- Type as titled
- investigative summary (kind from doc_type)
- File
- 6c5e12078b6598a7117658916872149df4c4665b application/pdf
- Cases
About: Michael Kim (case)
above his professional obligations, the public should be able to trust that Respondent is above reproach.
Reasonable Grounds that Respondent's Lack of Credibility is Disruptive to San Francisco Sheriff's Office's Ability to Maintain Discipline and Uphold Public Trust
As stated in the ISF on pages 10, 19, and 22-26, Respondent lacks credibility and there are reasonable grounds for regulatory action. During his interview, Respondent stated that he wrote a memorandum to then-Chief Deputy Matt Freeman that repeated the lies he told FBI Special Agents in August 2014. Respondent's lies disrupted the San Francisco Sheriff's Office's ability to maintain discipline, which is necessary to upholding and maintaining public trust and a culture of accountability.
Respondent's statements during his interview demonstrated a lack of candor, lack of accountability, and lack of awareness of the egregious nature of his conduct. Respondent stated during his interview that he spoke with numerous people at the San Francisco Sheriff's Office, including people within the chain of command, who told him the department would "love to have [him] back." As also described in the ISF, Dr. Dunnigan wrote that Respondent told him that "the Sheriff and background personnel . . . were comfortable with him coming back and working there." Yet, when Respondent named individuals in the chain of command or background investigations unit who supported his return to the department, the only person who had any part in the hiring process was Sheriff Paul Miyamoto. Respondent's lack of credibility further illustrates his inability to serve effectively as a peace officer.
Respondent minimized his conduct throughout his interview. For instance, he blamed Andy Li's lawyers who "badgered" him to sign the materially false Declaration. He also stated that the ballistic vest he gave Li was old, thin, and would likely have been available for sale on the open market.
Dr. Dunnigan's Interview
Dr. Dunnigan would not have found Respondent suitable but for the letter from Paul Miyamoto supporting Respondent's candidacy with the San Francisco Sheriff's Office.2 Dr. Dunnigan stated that letters from police chiefs and sheriffs were very unusual and Respondent's case included an "abnormal" process. Dr. Dunnigan stated that Respondent kept saying during the evaluation that he and Sheriff Miyamoto were very close and he would not have found Respondent suitable in the absence of the letter.
2 Through counsel, Respondent provided me during his interview with a digital copy of the letter. The digital properties showed the author as Paul Miyamoto and the last date it was modified was 2/15/2024.
Supplement to Investigative Summary and Findings
Michael Kim (Respondent)
Case Number POST2410050
Page 3 of 4
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.