Documents › 6af9ffbd9a807beb1a6aaadcbefcc860b07181a5:1-75

POSAAB Meeting Transcript February 5, 2026 - Elliott Lopez

POST board hearing transcriptboard proceeding 2026-02-05 75 pages (file pages 1–75) original file
About this document
Layer
attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
Type as titled
board hearing transcript (kind from doc_type)
File
6af9ffbd9a807beb1a6aaadcbefcc860b07181a5 application/pdf
Cases
POST 2402838 · Elliott Lopez (filed under case)

About: Elliott Lopez (case)

Page 29 · file page 29 larger image
Image of page 29; its text is alongside
Text: OCR

POSAAB Meeting, February 5, 2026

1 MR. HOFFMAN: Just — if I may add a point of
2 clarification on the point of consciousness or lack of
3 consciousness, under California law, a person who is
4 presumed to be conscious is a criminal defendant. And
5 they would have to produce — the burden is on the
6 defendant to produce that they were in an unconscious
7 state or a state of blackout beyond a reasonable doubt.

8 That's not necessarily the standard that we apply
9 here in the administrative process, but just to provide
10 a little bit further clarity on that topic.

11 CHAIRPERSON DUDLEY: Yeah. Thank you.

12 Because there wasn't a hearing, that never came up.
13 He pled nolo.

14 MR. HOFFMAN: Correct. We have no evidence either
15 way on that — in light of the —

16 CHAIRPERSON DUDLEY: And, yes. The administrative
17 standard of beyond a reasonable doubt versus clear and
18 convincing. Clearly different standards.

19 Anything else on this? Any other questions?

20 (No response.)

21 CHAIRPERSON DUDLEY: At this time, does the subject
22 officer and/or their counsel wish to make a public
23 statement?

24 And is he here or remote?

25 MS. DEL MUGNAIO: He's here.

108

SWANK REPORTING INC. (916) 390-7731

Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.