POST Interview of Ronnie Wan regarding Michael Kim
About this document
- Layer
- attachment: a document a meeting packet links to
- Type as titled
- interview transcript (kind from doc_type)
- File
- 69a045995f0e37fea1b47a24304e85a77ef95146 application/pdf
- Cases
About: Michael Kim (case)
Interview of Ronnie Wan
March 11, 2025
Page 3
the background investigation on July 13, 2023. The older background file was withdrawn the same date as the newer background file that ended up getting assigned to Wan.
Wan does not have the applicant initial at the bottom of each page of the PHQ. He was never taught that when he started in the background unit. If the applicant has any changes, Wan has them write in red ink. Red ink was in the old days of paper files. In Guardian, the background investigator cannot change the answers. The applicant has to sign back into Guardian and make the changes which are tracked by the system.
When Wan first got assigned to work Kim's background investigation, he went to his sergeant and lieutenant asked if they were sure they wanted to do this. They said to continue working it, so he worked it. Wan updates his superiors on what he was finding in the background investigation. The background investigator does not have any say in a disqualification, they just type in all the good and the bad and let the supervisor raise it up the chain. They look at it to make sure he completes all tasks. The supervisor reviews it for completeness and sends it up the chain if it's complete.
Shown the background investigation file for December 12, 2024, Wan explained that his supervisor is noted as approving the file, but that only meant that the file was complete and ready for review. The word "skipped" means the person might be on leave or out of the office.
When his sergeant or lieutenant have a note that they approved it, it means that they reviewed his work are certifying that he completed everything that he said he did and the file is approved for sending up the chain for hiring decision. Wan has never seen the word "declined." Starting Level 2 meant that it was the first time that the chain of command saw his report. When the file reached the level of Assistant Sheriff, Undersheriff, or Sheriff, that's when the "approved" note meant that the person had a vote and voted to approve or reject hiring the applicant. Even if everyone voted to reject an applicant, if the Sheriff said "yes, hire," then the applicant would be hired.
On page 375/376, the file noted that Kim received an email on November 30, 2023. Kim had failed the psychological evaluation. So, he had a chance to appeal. Wan understood that Kim failed the appeal (the second evaluation), so the rejection email went out. Some time later, Wan was told there was a change of mind by the doctor who reversed his earlier "not suitable" assessment and Kim's file went to the third doctor. Kim had failed his own psychologist. Wan did not know the reasons why he failed.
Wan was not sure where rejection reports would be kept. He only kept success letters. This was the very first time that Wan had seen two failures. He has seen 5-7 situations where an applicant failed their own doctor were rejected.
Wan did not hear that there was any pressure from above to pass Kim. They did want to see the file completed in a timely manner.
Kim always applied for a deputy position. Those are the only positions at SFSO, which does not have a corrections deputy position.
The mission of the California Commission on Peace Officer Standards and Training is to continually enhance the professionalism of California law enforcement in serving its communities.
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.