Documents › 63d552b96f35b443028446e20a1204ce6e11e2ca:8-26
508 - BR01_POST2305109_Satterfield, Joshua_ISF_Redacted.pdf
About this document
- Layer
- packet: an item in a POST meeting packet
- Type as titled
- isf (kind from doc_type)
- File
- 63d552b96f35b443028446e20a1204ce6e11e2ca application/pdf
- Cases
About: Joshua Satterfield (case)
Page 9 · file page 16
larger image
Text: digital text layer
Investigative Summary and Recommendation
Joshua G. Satterfield
Case Number POST2305109
Page 9 of 19
provide a statement. A sergeant from TPD admonished Respondent pursuant to
Lybarger9 and then the interview continued.
During the internal affairs investigation Respondent provided his cellular telephone
number to the investigator10. Respondentadvised he did not have another phone number
while he worked for TPD11. Respondent was not aware of anyone else using his cellular
telephone while he had that number. During Respondent’s internal affairs interview, his
counsel instructed him not to answer any questions related to information or data seized
as a result of the search warrant written for the personal telephones of Officers Tomsic
and Weldin.12
Because Respondent was refusing to answer questions related to the digital evidence,
Respondent was admonished by TPD Sergeant James Kyle that his continued refusal to
answer the specific questions presented to him by Internal Affairs Investigator Stauffer
could result in an additional policy violation of insubordination which could result in further
discipline, up to and including termination. Respondent continued to refuse to answer
questions directly related to the messages located on the telephones of Officers Tomsic
and Weldin. Respondent stated that he refused to answer these questions based on the
advice of his counsel.13
9 Lybarger v. City of Los Angeles, 40 Cal. 3d 825 (1985).
10 Respondent Transcripts 4/25/22 Interview Pg 5.
11 Respondent Transcripts 4/25/22 Transcript Pg 6.
12 Respondent’s counsel contended that TPD’s use of cellular phone information or data seized as a result of the
search warrant for Officers Tomsic and Weldin was a violation of Penal Code section 1546.1. Respondent’s
counsel’s contentions were later determined to be erroneous as a matter of law. On August 26, 2022, L.A.
Superior Court Judge William Ryan rejected Respondent’s motion to suppress evidence, and concluded TPD was
permitted to use the cellular phone information and ask questions of Respondent concerning the information.
Respondent appealed this ruling; however, the appeal was dismissed by order of the 2nd Appellate District Court of
Appeal on January 29, 2024. (See Chavez et al. v. Torrance Police Department et al. (California Court of Appeal
Case No. B324472).)
13 Depending upon the facts in a given case, an officer’s refusal to answer questions, even when based on the
advice of counsel, could constitute a failure to cooperate with an investigation into potential police misconduct
within the meaning of Penal Code section 13510.8(b)(9). The Division did not find clear and convincing evidence of
a failure to cooperate in this case.
16
Keys: ← → or j k turn pages; / finds.